Originally Posted by MrJames:
“2007 - Dannii and Simon apparently have an affair, Dannii is rendered rather pointless on screen.
You can see where Sharon is coming from although I don't really condone her constant vitriol.
However,
2010 - Dannii is a mother, sophisticated, stylish, a brilliant mentor and most popular judge.
Just like all the other eras of X Factor over the years, things change and things evolve, and Dannii got it just right in the show's most iconic year.”
Thats why it was so successful that year and they're trying to emulate it, realise it isn't working, and then change it again the following year.
Dannii (and Cheryl for that matter) both developed on the show. They weren't big names before they joined. They were known, but they both only hit the stratosphere after being on X Factor.
As for this thread, its definitely how Dannii got the job which is questionable ethics and makes a laughing stock of her appointment and first year or so as a judge, but it worked out in the long run. It would've been interesting to see what would've happened if they ditched Dannii after series 4 and had series 5-7 with Simon, Cheryl, Louis and Sharon.