Originally Posted by Three Left Feet:
“I wonder if T&D had forgotten the politics that always went with ice skating. Each year, there was always a "feeling" relayed by the commentators that it was so-and-so's "turn" to win. I recall that whilst the Russian pro pair (Gordieva and Grinkov?) were welcomed back, there wasn't the same feeling towards T&D. Probably something to do with the strong Eastern bloc representatation in the Ice Dancing world and the fact that T&D were filthy rich after their pro careers.
Thus, it wasn't their "turn", and if it's not your turn, you're up against it, particularly given the make-up of the judging panel and the traditional East/West split of voting tendencies.
Thus, it was always likely that anything T&D did that was marginal would be held against them, whereas the Russians would be given much more latitude.
I guess even if they'd not done the lift that was judged illegal (irrespective of whether it was actually illegal) they'd still have lost, but by doing it, they gave the judges all the ammunition they needed.”
Don't forget that Olympic Freedance was only cobbled together in the preceeding couple of weeks after Europeans, which they unexpectedly won by a mathematical placement skating their original routine which was much more step based, going by the edict laid down by the ISU Ice Dance Technical Committee for that season. Chris Howarth described it as "staid" and watching a German channel on my old Astra satellite dish around Christmas, the German Ice Dance Judge said she expected T&D to finish "3rd" - and that was before anyone had skated.
No, they weren't welcomed back, and none of the single skater pros who returned, like Kati Witt and Brian Bitano, went on to win either. As you say, only G&G did, though I preferred Mishkoutinok & Dimitriev's Free to Rachmaninov's Piano Concerto No.2 myself.
Apart from T&D's comeback upsetting the Russians, those couples lower down, who had hoped to make the podium if they skated great, like Rakhamo/Kokko of Finland, had their noses put out of joint, and said so in a book a decade ago.