what does a white poppy mean

4 of 4

JohnQuig

10-11-2013

I won't wear a poppy, I find it's just propaganda to get you to support the troops. Sorry, but it's true. If you want to remember them, do it privately, don't force it upon anyone else.

My reasons are slightly more personal, with there being a lot of Irish in my family and the Bloody Sunday massacre personally effecting relatives of mine, I simply can't honour soldiers that murdered innocent people.

superbass88

10-11-2013

Originally Posted by JohnQuig:
“I won't wear a poppy, I find it's just propaganda to get you to support the troops. Sorry, but it's true. If you want to remember them, do it privately, don't force it upon anyone else.

My reasons are slightly more personal, with there being a lot of Irish in my family and the Bloody Sunday massacre personally effecting relatives of mine, I simply can't honour soldiers that murdered innocent people.”

I'm the same, the money paid for the poppy will go towards those soldiers who served in Ireland as well and I'm not comfortable with that..

PorkchopExpress

10-11-2013

Originally Posted by floozie_21:
“Thank you.

Roland Mouse - just because this is what it means to me doesn't mean I'm telling everyone else to stop wearing a red poppy. I said in my previous post, the poppies mean different things to different people.”

Roland, when posting indignantly about Remembrance on this thread, said that those who disagreed with him on this should be put against a wall and shot.

Pretty crass, at the very least.

SULLA

10-11-2013

Originally Posted by PorkchopExpress:
“It's pleasing to me that more and more people actually think about the poppy nowadays and more people are beginning to challenge the jingoistic glorification of war and soldier worship the media imposes on ordinary people. 10 years ago people just wore the poppy and tugged their forelocks without questioning but I suppose we have had the atrocities of Iraq and Afghanistan since then.

That and the media pushing and pushing to the point where people start to get sick of it.

I truly think the world is beginning to move on and for that I am thankful. The BBC and their "Festival" of "Remembrance" really is awful though.”

A strange attitude for someone who has the same name as a famous battle.

patricia50

10-11-2013

I suspect that porkchopexpress has achieved the desired reaction with his/her comments. If trolling makes him/ her feel better, how sad.

floozie_21

10-11-2013

Originally Posted by patricia50:
“I suspect that porkchopexpress has achieved the desired reaction with his/her comments. If trolling makes him/ her feel better, how sad.”

What part was trolling?

garbage456

10-11-2013

Originally Posted by PorkchopExpress:
“I don't like the military, and I don't like war. I detest the annual celebration and glorification of war that the Poppy drivel has become.

Remembrance itself has it's place, but when it becomes indulgent, mawkish, jingoistic and agenda driven I don't want to know. And there should come a time when people move on and stop "remembering".

This year's poppy drivel has been more low key in the media than in recent years. A welcome development and hopefully a sign of things to come.”

It's not a celebration.

gv6l

10-11-2013

Originally Posted by floozie_21:
“I wouldn't be surprised if it was chosen because it went better with the outfit!”

Exactly!
She's wearing a red poppy here

http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/tv/s103/...sang-best.html
Last edited by gv6l : 10-11-2013 at 18:20

PorkchopExpress

10-11-2013

Originally Posted by garbage456:
“It's not a celebration.”

With the "Festival" of Remembrance you could have fooled me.

PorkchopExpress

10-11-2013

Originally Posted by patricia50:
“I suspect that porkchopexpress has achieved the desired reaction with his/her comments. If trolling makes him/ her feel better, how sad.”

These are my sincerely held views and they are pretty mainstream as demonstrated by the level of support on the thread. Why do you wish to dismiss them as trolling? Is it to make yourself feel better?

4 of 4