He's alright but he really needs to sort his shorts out

i liked russell kane

this guy doesn't make me laugh

rob is brilliant !!! Not keen on Joe but he's OK

whenever he appears on the screen I have an urge to hammer a nail through his forehead

I like Rob very much, he's great on the show, as is the delightful Laura!


I could do without Swash quite easily though.

He's quite strange but seems nice enough. Not that funny but better than Russell Kane.

I didn't like Russel Kane much either

a ringing endorsement if ever I have seen one, he'll probably use your quote to market his next tour

funny how everyone hates joe swash, yet he won back in 2008. it's his voice/accent thats annoying

He seems like a nice enough guy but for me his comedy bits don't really work. Rather than cutting to him and having slightly forced observations dressed up rather poorly as stand up, he should just be on the panel. At least he offers something, unlike a certain Mr Swash, and I think he would work ok in that role.
Whilst I didn't think Russell Kane was amazing, I think he was far better when he was on, and his 'stand up' sections were better observed, sharper, and most importantly funnier!

I haven't seen him yet

Not really. Plenty of people must like him as they voted for him, but I wouldn't think they are the same people stating their dislike for him on this thread.