Originally Posted by Jan2555*GG*:
“Ok so the BBC engineer their 'employees' to win.
So we have 10 current Strictly Champions.
Series 1 Natasha Kaplinsky. Yes she worked for the BBC it was series 1 everything was new
Series 2 Jill Halfpenny not connected to BBC
Series 3 Darren Gough Sportsman
Series 4 Mark Ramps Sportsman
Series 5 Alesha Dixon (they could easily have arranged for their BBC employee Gethin to win but they most DEFINATELY didn't in fact the opposir)
Series 6 Tom Chambers. He worked on a BBC show but they didn't want him to win
Series 7 Chris Hollins BBC but again they did their best to try & stop him winning
Series 8 Kara Tointon not BBC
Series 9 Harry Judd musician
Series 10 Louis Smith sportsman
If you can give me examples of how they engineer this almost complete failure of getting a BBC winner I would be interested to hear it”
You need to distinguish between the BBc, TPTB and the judges. Their agendas can completely different and often conflicted. The bbc has the least direct power and the judges the most, but still it is pretty obvious if you also consider finalists.
eries 1 Natasha Kaplinsky. she worked for the BBC
Series 2 Jill Halfpenny - ex eastenders, connected to BBC
Series 3 Darren Gough Sportsman
Series 4 Mark Ramps Sportsman
Series 5 Alesha Dixon (they could easily have arranged for their BBC employee Gethin to win but they most DEFINATELY didn't in fact the opposite, but that was judges doing rather than bbc, Matt do Angelo was in eastenders and later in the con man series.)
Series 6 Tom Chambers. He worked on a BBC show - judges didn't but TPTB or Bbc didn't do much against. In fact, they realised the mistake in semi final and helped him get in the final (even for strictly legal reasons).
Series 7 Chris Hollins - BBC and TPTB they did their best for him winning and pretty anti Ricky.
Series 8 Kara Tointon - ex eastenders BBC - that year also Matt baker (bbc pushed him to win, but TPTB and judges would not have it) and Scott maslen (eastenders, all very positive)
Series 9 Harry Judd musician
Series 10 Louis Smith sportsman
So if we separate the three aspects and consider recent history, don't things change?