Sophie already won this show in Week 2.

3 of 3

chels.p

24-11-2013

Originally Posted by Sherlock_Holmes:
“Wrong on both accounts.

The only thing worse then an agenda from the judges is an agenda from posters (personally, I would make a happy thread about MY favourite.........but this is perhaps better for some people ).

Is this an appeal to stop people voting for Sophie & Brendan? See, I just don't get the logic.

Personally, I think that Natalie has been severely overmarked the last few weeks (Sophie was even better then her this and last week), but I don't feel in any way compelled to make a thread about it.”

Or maybe it's just the genuine opinion of the OP? I agree completely with them - apart from them saying Sophie's rumba was terrible because i thought it was rather good - I think she's definitely going to win. She just has the right personality. Having said that, unless she does a big comeback before the final (which I still think she can), based on dancing merit she will have pretty much have won on one dance and I'm not sure how I'd feel about that. I think some solid ballroom performances before the final could make her a really good winner.

Sherlock_Holmes

24-11-2013

Originally Posted by chels.p:
“Or maybe it's just the genuine opinion of the OP? I agree completely with them - apart from them saying Sophie's rumba was terrible because i thought it was rather good - I think she's definitely going to win. She just has the right personality. Having said that, unless she does a big comeback before the final (which I still think she can), based on dancing merit she will have pretty much have won on one dance and I'm not sure how I'd feel about that. I think some solid ballroom performances before the final could make her a really good winner.”

Foxtrot?
Quickstep?
AT?

And no, she is not going to win. Trust me on that. She will be lucky enough to make the final, as in the quarterfinal and the sem-final she will be dead last on the judges leaderboard (almost 100% sure, dances are not important). And she can only go through based on the placing of the other couples (i.e. luck).

chels.p

24-11-2013

Originally Posted by Sherlock_Holmes:
“Foxtrot?
Quickstep?
AT?

And no, she is not going to win. Trust me on that. She will be lucky enough to make the final, as in the quarterfinal and the sem-final she will be dead last on the judges leaderboard (almost 100% sure, dances are not important). And she can only go through based on the placing of the other couples (i.e. luck).”

We'll have to wait and see I guess...but I'm pretty sure she'll have a "comeback" dance - three 10s, four 10s - before the final

yellowlabbie

24-11-2013

Originally Posted by madetomeasure:
“[/b]

That's your interpretation, certainly isn't mine. Tonight was not about excuse making, he was completely frustrated that the Judges couldn't see how unique it was. Great to see, rather than some weeks, no props either, just beautiful artistic dancing telling a story.”

It was so unique, it wasn't a rumba. It's easy to dance beautifully if you don't bother with any hip action. She was supposed to dance a rumba and she didn't.

She also looks like she doesn't even want to be there.

Sofajudge

24-11-2013

Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“It was so unique, it wasn't a rumba. It's easy to dance beautifully if you don't bother with any hip action. She was supposed to dance a rumba and she didn't.

She also looks like she doesn't even want to be there.”

No, I don't buy that at all. She seemed perfectly happy until she got to the judges bench.

Jan2555*GG*

24-11-2013

Originally Posted by Sofajudge:
“No, I don't buy that at all. She seemed perfectly happy until she got to the judges bench.”

Then she found out that Brendan had been lying to her by saying it was ok to do a 'cool & different' Rumba. Which actually means it's not a Rumba

yellowlabbie

24-11-2013

Originally Posted by Sofajudge:
“No, I don't buy that at all. She seemed perfectly happy until she got to the judges bench.”

She obviously didn't like to hear the truth then?

Jan2555*GG*

24-11-2013

Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“She obviously didn't like to hear the truth then?”

To be fair it's Brendan who has been keeping the truth from her. He is letting her down by treating her like a china doll which she may look like but isn't. He needs to get real.

Sofajudge

24-11-2013

Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“She obviously didn't like to hear the truth then?”

Who does when it's negative...

cinna

24-11-2013

Originally Posted by Jan2555*GG*:
“To be fair it's Brendan who has been keeping the truth from her. He is letting her down by treating her like a china doll which she may look like but isn't. He needs to get real.”

With about as much personality as said china doll.

3 of 3