Originally Posted by Sherlock_Holmes:
“Luisa did have a few bad weeks, think it was the week she won as PM (milkshake task??) and Lord Sugar made a nasty comment to her. Also, the abdication (sp?) episode wasn't exactly great for her. But, as mentioned, it was a mystery as to how Fran got that far (mind you, Helene from series 4 also kinda made the final). It was a female final, but I don't think (based on the tasks) that anyone would have been surprised or shocked if the final had been between Jordan and Neil.”
At the time, Luisa's PMship was criticised by her team. I can't really remember as I have only seen that episode once, but on the treat she said that she actually disagreed with the team and thought that she did a good job, so it's something that is open to interpretation. In the
Final Five show, her role on that task was praised, so there was clearly more to it than meets the eye. I thought she was pretty good on Task 8 as well. The way she spoke to Jason was described as being appallingly bad manners, but I didn't see it like that. I think that she just wanted to win the task, and felt that Jason was going about it all wrong and that she'd do a better job - and even though they still lost, I think that she did do better than Jason. There's nothing wrong with pointing out what your PM is doing wrong if you feel you can do a better job - Claire is criticised for doing it with Simon in Series 4, but I feel exactly the same way about that. I didn't think Claire was being unpleasant, just critical. Kristina does it to Paul in the France task, but no one has any issue with that - quite rightly so.