Originally Posted by Veri:
“No, they can't. They can dislike without knowing what caused it, but that's not the same as it having no cause. "I just don't like her" is the final fallback when someone has failed to come up with good enough reasons for their degree of dislike.
Besides, if someone disliked for no reason, why would they consider that dislike important enough for them to repeatedly and vehemently express it?
That's a pretty questionable assumption, actually. For some of those defending her aren't her fans, some who defend her (including some fans) don't think jealousy's the reason, and among those who do think jealousy is a factor, the most common view seems to be that jealousy was, or may well be, involved in some cases (especially Lucy), not that all the dislike is due to jealousy.
If they did, they'd at least have to admit that jealousy can be a factor, contrary to the instant (and often sarcastic) dismissal many have been giving to the idea.
And then they could consider that different people can dislike for different reasons, so that jealousy can be the main reason for some without it being the reason for all.”
So for those who don't think jealousy is a reason, what it their, well, your reason for why the campmates found her unsympathetic?
And for those who think jealousy is only a possible reason for not all the people, why do they think it is then so important?
And do they think the 'other reasons' they have are viable on their own? If so, why do they bother with it?
What are these OTHER reasons Veri, that makes YOU think the campmates found Amy so difficult?
And many people have admitted jealousy COULD be a factor, including me, although without evidence that any of them definitely were, that can be very reasonably disputed, and plenty of evidence that others found her dislikable who aren't considered 'jealous', this 'COULD be jealous' argument, just DOESN'T MATTER.