So the end of the year is approaching and what a great year for Doctor Who, 50th anniversary has been celebrated and at Christmas we will say goodbye to Matt Smith and hello to Peter Capaldi. So to finish the year a good old game of Hurt or Heal to find your favourite Doctor and the order of which the doctors are liked.

The rules are the same as usual - give +1 to the Doctor you want to heal, and -1 to the Doctor you want to hurt. You can do this once every 24 hours. All Doctors start on 10 points, once a doctor gets to 0, whoever the next poster is you should add an 'Regenerated' list below with the eliminated Doctor and then continue adding until only the winner remains.

I have not included John Hurts War Doctor but you may give a special mention to him if he is a favourite of yours.

So, without further ado, I present The Doctor's Hurt and Heal game:

William Hartnell - 10
Patrick Troughton - 10
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 10
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 10
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 10
Christopher Eccleston - 10
David Tennant - 10
Matt Smith - 10

So I will start:

William Hartnell - 10
Patrick Troughton - 10
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 10
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 09 (-1)
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 11 (+1)
Christopher Eccleston - 10
David Tennant - 10
Matt Smith - 10

William Hartnell - 11 +1
Patrick Troughton - 10
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 10
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 09
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 11
Christopher Eccleston - 10
David Tennant - 9 (-1)
Matt Smith - 10

William Hartnell - 11
Patrick Troughton - 10
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 11 +1
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 09
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 11
Christopher Eccleston - 9 -1
David Tennant - 9
Matt Smith - 10

William Hartnell - 11
Patrick Troughton - 10
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 11
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 9
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 11
Christopher Eccleston - 8 -1
David Tennant - 9
Matt Smith - 11 +1

William Hartnell - 12 (+1)
Patrick Troughton - 10
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 11
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 09
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 11
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 8 (-1)
Matt Smith - 11

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 10
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 11
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 8 -1 Hurt
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 11
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 9 +1 Heal
Matt Smith - 11

Has anyone spotted the mistake Tom Baker should have been on 12 points from WhoMad's post! so lets red it:




OK I will now add mine:

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 10
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 12
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 7 -1
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 11
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 9
Matt Smith - 11 +1

No he should not, tom baker has only had one +1 so 11 and you forgot to change matt smiths when you added 1 and should be 12 so correct current list is:


William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 10
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 11
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 7 -1
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 11
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 9
Matt Smith - 12 +1

OK sorry Im new to the game, thanks for clearing that up!

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 10
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 11
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 7
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 12 (+1)
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 9
Matt Smith - 11 (-1)

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 9 (-1)
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 11
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 8 (+1)
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 12
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 9
Matt Smith - 11

John Hurt - Special Mention

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 9
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 11
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 7 (-1)
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 13 (+1)
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 9
Matt Smith - 11

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 9
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 12 (+1)
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 6 (-1)
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 13
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 9
Matt Smith - 11

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 8 (-1)
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 12 (+1)
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 7 (+1)
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 13
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 9
Matt Smith - 11

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 8
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 12
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 7
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 13
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 8 (-1)
Matt Smith - 12 (+1)

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 8
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 12
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 6 (-1)
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 14 (+1)
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 8
Matt Smith - 12

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 9 (+)
Jon Pertwee - 10
Tom Baker - 12
Peter Davison - 9 (-)
Colin Baker - 6
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 14
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 8
Matt Smith - 12

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 9
Jon Pertwee - 9 (-1)
Tom Baker - 12
Peter Davison - 9
Colin Baker - 7 (+1)
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 14
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 8
Matt Smith - 12

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 9
Jon Pertwee - 9
Tom Baker - 12
Peter Davison - 10 (+1)
Colin Baker - 6 (-1)
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 14
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 8
Matt Smith - 12

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 9
Jon Pertwee - 9
Tom Baker - 13 (+1)
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 6
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 14
Christopher Eccleston - 8
David Tennant - 7 (-1)
Matt Smith - 12

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 9
Jon Pertwee - 9
Tom Baker - 13 (+1)
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 6
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 14
Christopher Eccleston - 7 (-1)
David Tennant - 8 (+1)
Matt Smith - 12

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 9
Jon Pertwee - 9
Tom Baker - 13
Peter Davison - 10
Colin Baker - 6
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 15 (+1)
Christopher Eccleston - 6 (-1)
David Tennant - 8
Matt Smith - 12

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 9
Jon Pertwee - 9
Tom Baker - 14 (+1)
Peter Davison - 9 (-1)
Colin Baker - 6
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 15
Christopher Eccleston - 6
David Tennant - 8
Matt Smith - 12

Edit: Special Mention to John Hurt

William Hartnell - 12
Patrick Troughton - 9
Jon Pertwee - 9
Tom Baker - 13 (HURT)
Peter Davison - 9
Colin Baker - 6
Sylvester McCoy - 10
Paul McGann - 16 (HEAL)
Christopher Eccleston - 6
David Tennant - 8
Matt Smith - 12

Special Mention to John Hurt