I too don't understand the praise this woman gets just because she is moving slightly less robotically than she has done in the past. That said, her dancing is till sloppy, clumsy and out of time. She is a shadow of the performer she used to be.
As for the miming, I think it's a bloody disgrace that people even try to justify that. She is so complacent and lazy that she doesn't even attempt to sing. What exactly are people paying to see? I'd be fairly confident that half the girls in the audience could get up on stage and dance just as well as she does here, while miming to her tracks. So why the hell is she getting paid a fortune for it? I just don't understand it at all. She is actively proving that she has little to no natural talent or ability every time she gets on that stage and fakes it.
Really, if you think about it, she's not a singer at all because she doesn't actually sing a note. When she's on tour, she's really just a dancer now, and when she's getting outdanced by every one of her backing dancers ten times over, that's a pretty embarrassing position to be in really.