• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Doctor Who
Who are people voting for...
bokonon
17-01-2014
... in the DWM Special Contribution Award.

And for those who haven't seen it you are asked to choose your top three people from across all fifty years of Doctor Who.

I am umming and ahhing but am currently going for Robert Holmes, Steven Moffatt and Delia Derbyshire. (The Doctors and Companions are covered elsewhere of course.)

Also...

When voting on the stories are people giving a lot of tens? My provisional estimate is that I am awarding about a dozen. I am not sure if this is generous or mean.

And lastly....

What policy are people adopting on episodes they half remember but haven't actually seen since first broadcast? I am pretty sure I enjoyed the Seeds of Doom when I was six or seven but havent seen it since then (bad fan).
Tom Tit
17-01-2014
Delia Derbyshire is a choice I would get behind because she never got the official recognition she deserved as co-writer (at the very least) of the Doctor Who theme music.
saladfingers81
17-01-2014
I wasn't aware they were running this poll. Seems a bit silly. I understand the episodes one but picking three who are most significant? Bound to be divisive. I would struggle to narrow it down to 30.
Tom Tit
17-01-2014
Originally Posted by saladfingers81:
“I wasn't aware they were running this poll. Seems a bit silly. I understand the episodes one but picking three who are most significant? Bound to be divisive. I would struggle to narrow it down to 30.”


I haven't seen it but I would assume it's supposed to be a way to honour somebody who wouldn't otherwise be in an applicable category (such as the fore-mentioned Delia Derbyshire) rather than just 'most important people'? If is the latter, I agree, ridiculous concept.
bokonon
17-01-2014
Originally Posted by Tom Tit:
“I haven't seen it but I would assume it's supposed to be a way to honour somebody who wouldn't otherwise be in an applicable category (such as the fore-mentioned Delia Derbyshire) rather than just 'most important people'? If is the latter, I agree, ridiculous concept.”

Well you get to vote for favourite Doctor, favourite companion and the third one is the Special Contribution Award which is defined in the way I indicated in the original post- which I didn't find terribly helpful.

I have to say I think the funniest thing about the poll is that it is still being done on a bit of paper sent via the post. I do hope they transcribe my numbers accurately. Perhaps this is what has been supporting the inflated price of Royal Mail shares. Ha.
Tom Tit
17-01-2014
Originally Posted by bokonon:
“Well you get to vote for favourite Doctor, favourite companion and the third one is the Special Contribution Award which is defined in the way I indicated in the original post- which I didn't find terribly helpful.

I have to say I think the funniest thing about the poll is that it is still being done on a bit of paper sent via the post. I do hope they transcribe my numbers accurately. Perhaps this is what has been supporting the inflated price of Royal Mail shares. Ha.”


Strange that they don't have an individual category for writers. For me that would be what I would be most interested in voting for.
saladfingers81
17-01-2014
Originally Posted by Tom Tit:
“I haven't seen it but I would assume it's supposed to be a way to honour somebody who wouldn't otherwise be in an applicable category (such as the fore-mentioned Delia Derbyshire) rather than just 'most important people'? If is the latter, I agree, ridiculous concept.”

Agree. An 'unsung hero' award would be great. And basically Delia D would and should win. But the way I read the original post was it is anyone you think has made a special contribution to the show. Where do you start? I should probably check it out. I only pick up DWM on a month to month basis having cancelled my sub.
bokonon
17-01-2014
Originally Posted by saladfingers81:
“Agree. An 'unsung hero' award would be great. And basically Delia D would and should win. But the way I read the original post was it is anyone you think has made a special contribution to the show. Where do you start? I should probably check it out. I only pick up DWM on a month to month basis having cancelled my sub.”

As I said in my original post the unhelpful instructions are: 'Choose your top three people from across 50 years of Doctor Who'. I assume most people wont vote for Doctors or Companions as they have already had the chance.
Tom Tit
17-01-2014
Originally Posted by saladfingers81:
“Agree. An 'unsung hero' award would be great. And basically Delia D would and should win. But the way I read the original post was it is anyone you think has made a special contribution to the show. Where do you start? I should probably check it out. I only pick up DWM on a month to month basis having cancelled my sub.”

I just read it in the shop at the train station Lasts a good month in 20 minute patches that way
Shoppy
18-01-2014
Originally Posted by Tom Tit:
“Delia Derbyshire is a choice I would get behind because she never got the official recognition she deserved as co-writer (at the very least) of the Doctor Who theme music.”

This.

Even those who have never seen the show know that music means Doctor Who.

lady_xanax
18-01-2014
Originally Posted by Shoppy:
“This.

Even those who have never seen the show know that music means Doctor Who.

”

Agree- it's iconic. There have been some horrible versions of it though, including something that sounds Australian. I think it was one of the Pertwee ones.

Some of the opening credits are very creepy, probably because Davison's the only Doctor who's face doesn't look terrifying when it looms at you. I know that as a child I wouldn't have been able to get past that Colin Baker opening!
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map