Originally Posted by An Thropologist:
“I don't find that pair of arguments logical.
If Lee was telling the truth about Casey contriving a showmance for the purposes of airtime the yes she would be playing a game. But that means your characterisation of Lee fails.
If you maintain he has lied and made the stuff up about her it exonerates her I feel. If she has been spurned by Lee who then lied about what she said, her behaviour is understandable and not deserving of the descriptions attributed to her.
Its one or the other. From what we have seen, so far, it is Lee who is lying. Time will tell (maybe) but you can't have it both ways.
As for 'Luisa hasn't been hurtful, sly or two faced' - well that's your opinion, but not one I share. She goes beyond outspoken and her insistence on her right to tell it as she sees it, with all people at all times is often hurtful. As she would well know if she took a step out of her ego centric world. She gets upset when its coming to her but doesn't seem able to grasp that's how others feel when she is delivering her brutal honest opinion (again!)
She is entertaining and is certainly not all bad but IMO painting her as a plaster saint is not credible.”
Bravo AT! Brilliantly put.
”
