New Doctor Who Hurt and Heal game with Classic and New sections.

2 of 5

YoungAtHeart

27-01-2014

Paul McGann isn't New Who. New Who started with Chris Ecclestone.

lotrjw

27-01-2014

Originally Posted by YoungAtHeart:
“Paul McGann isn't New Who. New Who started with Chris Ecclestone. ”

I refer you to what I said earlier:

Originally Posted by lotrjw:
“Paul McGann is in New Who as he was in Night of the Doctor and the TV movie was after the classics finished”

http://forums.digitalspy.co.uk/showp...29&postcount=5

Satmanager

27-01-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 13
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 10
Tom Baker 17 HEAL
Peter Davison 8 HURT
Sylvester McCoy 12

Regenerated:
6th Colin Baker 25/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 12
John Hurt 18 HEAL
David Tennant 11
Matt Smith 11
Peter Capaldi 8 HURT

Regenerated:
9th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014

Vopiscus

27-01-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 14 HEAL
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 10
Tom Baker 17
Peter Davison 7 HURT
Sylvester McCoy 12

Regenerated:
6th Colin Baker 25/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 12
John Hurt 18
David Tennant 10 HURT
Matt Smith 11
Peter Capaldi 9 HEAL

Regenerated:
9th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014

lotrjw

28-01-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 14
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 10
Tom Baker 17
Peter Davison 6 HURT
Sylvester McCoy 13 HEAL

Regenerated:
6th Colin Baker 25/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 12
John Hurt 18
David Tennant 9 HURT
Matt Smith 11
Peter Capaldi 10 HEAL

Regenerated:
9th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014

Satmanager

28-01-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 14
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 10
Tom Baker 18 HEAL
Peter Davison 5 HURT
Sylvester McCoy 13

Regenerated:
6th Colin Baker 25/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 12
John Hurt 19 HEAL
David Tennant 8 HURT
Matt Smith 11
Peter Capaldi 10

Regenerated:
9th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014

lotrjw

29-01-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 14
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 10
Tom Baker 18
Peter Davison 4 HURT
Sylvester McCoy 14 HEAL

Regenerated:
7th Colin Baker 25/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 12
John Hurt 19
David Tennant 7 HURT
Matt Smith 11
Peter Capaldi 11 HEAL

Regenerated:
6th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014

Satmanager

29-01-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 14
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 10
Tom Baker 19 HEAL
Peter Davison 3 HURT
Sylvester McCoy 14

Regenerated:
7th Colin Baker 25/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 12
John Hurt 20 HEAL
David Tennant 6 HURT
Matt Smith 11
Peter Capaldi 11

Regenerated:
6th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014

lotrjw

30-01-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 14
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 10
Tom Baker 19
Peter Davison 2 HURT
Sylvester McCoy 15 HEAL

Regenerated:
7th Colin Baker 25/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 12
John Hurt 20
David Tennant 5 HURT
Matt Smith 11
Peter Capaldi 12 HEAL

Regenerated:
6th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014

doormouse1

30-01-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 14
Patrick Troughton 11 HEAL
Jon Pertwee 10
Tom Baker 19
Peter Davison 1 HURT
Sylvester McCoy 15

Regenerated:
7th Colin Baker 25/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 13 HEAL
John Hurt 20
David Tennant 4 HURT
Matt Smith 11
Peter Capaldi 12

Regenerated:
6th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014

Satmanager

30-01-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 14
Patrick Troughton 11
Jon Pertwee 10
Tom Baker 20 HEAL
Peter Davison 0 HURT
Sylvester McCoy 15

Regenerated:
7th Colin Baker 25/01/2014
6th Peter Davison 30/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 13
John Hurt 21 HEAL
David Tennant 3 HURT
Matt Smith 11
Peter Capaldi 12

Regenerated:
6th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014

lotrjw

31-01-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 14
Patrick Troughton 10 HURT
Jon Pertwee 10
Tom Baker 20
Sylvester McCoy 16 HEAL

Regenerated:
7th Colin Baker 25/01/2014
6th Peter Davison 30/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 13
John Hurt 21
David Tennant 2 HURT
Matt Smith 12 HEAL
Peter Capaldi 12

Regenerated:
6th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014

Vopiscus

31-01-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 15 HEAL
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 10
Tom Baker 20
Sylvester McCoy 15 HURT

Regenerated:
7th Colin Baker 25/01/2014
6th Peter Davison 30/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 13
John Hurt 21
David Tennant 1 HURT
Matt Smith 13 HEAL
Peter Capaldi 12

Regenerated:
6th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014

Satmanager

31-01-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 15
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 9 HURT
Tom Baker 21 HEAL
Sylvester McCoy 15

Regenerated:
7th Colin Baker 25/01/2014
6th Peter Davison 30/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 13
John Hurt 22 HEAL
David Tennant 0 HURT
Matt Smith 13
Peter Capaldi 12

Regenerated:
6th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014
5th David Tennant 31/01/2014

lotrjw

01-02-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 15
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 8 HURT
Tom Baker 21
Sylvester McCoy 16 HEAL

Regenerated:
7th Colin Baker 25/01/2014
6th Peter Davison 30/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 11 HURT
John Hurt 22
Matt Smith 13
Peter Capaldi 13 HEAL

Regenerated:
6th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014
5th David Tennant 31/01/2014

Ok just a quick point to keep in with what I set up at the start, New Who section is now down to four Doctors so:

Quote:
“Third: when it gets down to four Doctors (per section) then its 2 Hurts to 1 heal each and if a Doctor ends up on minus 1 from a 2 Hurt at regeneration, then one or the hurts can go to a second Doctor.”

So New Who is 2 hurts to one heal which means it could end New Who a lot quicker than Classic Who section!

The_Judge_

01-02-2014

Missed most of this thread, try not to kill too many docs off while I try and read through the rules ....

lotrjw

01-02-2014

Originally Posted by The_Judge_:
“Missed most of this thread, try not to kill too many docs off while I try and read through the rules ....”

Its OK I dont think they will go too quick! the extra rules are just so the game doesnt drag out!
Although having two categories has sped things up too!

Next time though as there was complaints about Paul McGann and Capaldi I think the next game will categorise the Doctors into 60s & 70s, 80s & 90s and 2000s
Meaning McGann will be in the 80s & 90s and Capaldi will have to wait till September maybe?

The_Judge_

01-02-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 15
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 7 HURT
Tom Baker 22 HEAL
Sylvester McCoy 16

Regenerated:
7th Colin Baker 25/01/2014
6th Peter Davison 30/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 11
John Hurt 20 HURT
Matt Smith 14 HEAL
Peter Capaldi 13

Regenerated:
6th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014
5th David Tennant 31/01/2014

Vopiscus

01-02-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 16 HEAL
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 7
Tom Baker 22
Sylvester McCoy 15 HURT

Regenerated:
7th Colin Baker 25/01/2014
6th Peter Davison 30/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 12 HEAL
John Hurt 18 HURT
Matt Smith 14
Peter Capaldi 13

Regenerated:
6th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014
5th David Tennant 31/01/2014

Satmanager

01-02-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 16
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 6 HURT
Tom Baker 23 HEAL
Sylvester McCoy 15

Regenerated:
7th Colin Baker 25/01/2014
6th Peter Davison 30/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 10 HURT
John Hurt 19 HEAL
Matt Smith 14
Peter Capaldi 13

Regenerated:
6th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014
5th David Tennant 31/01/2014

Satmanager

01-02-2014

Originally Posted by lotrjw:
“Its OK I dont think they will go too quick! the extra rules are just so the game doesnt drag out!
Although having two categories has sped things up too!

Next time though as there was complaints about Paul McGann and Capaldi I think the next game will categorise the Doctors into 60s & 70s, 80s & 90s and 2000s
Meaning McGann will be in the 80s & 90s and Capaldi will have to wait till September maybe?”

I would rather see the next game being one with the companions. I think the Doctors have been gamed to death by now. I do like the idea with the division as above with the companions.

lotrjw

02-02-2014

Originally Posted by Satmanager:
“I would rather see the next game being one with the companions. I think the Doctors have been gamed to death by now. I do like the idea with the division as above with the companions.”

ok well a list of companions will need to be created and then divided like your saying into double decades. Will we have companions that have only done one or two episodes or just ones that have been with the Doctor a while?

Satmanager

02-02-2014

Originally Posted by lotrjw:
“ok well a list of companions will need to be created and then divided like your saying into double decades. Will we have companions that have only done one or two episodes or just ones that have been with the Doctor a while?”

I would say multiple episodes ( >10 as a cutoff) so we have an emotional bond with the companion.

lotrjw

02-02-2014

Originally Posted by Satmanager:
“I would say multiple episodes ( >10 as a cutoff) so we have an emotional bond with the companion.”

ok cool

*Eileen*

02-02-2014

Classic Who:

William Hartnell 17 HEAL
Patrick Troughton 10
Jon Pertwee 6
Tom Baker 23
Sylvester McCoy 14 HURT

Regenerated:
7th Colin Baker 25/01/2014
6th Peter Davison 30/01/2014

New Who:

Paul McGann 10
John Hurt 19
Matt Smith 15 HEAL
Peter Capaldi 12 HURT

Regenerated:
6th Christopher Eccleston 27/01/2014
5th David Tennant 31/01/2014

2 of 5