Originally Posted by natalian:
“Why is everyone so certain that Chris could have challenged Ray? Suzanne beat Chris and she isn't beating Ray so there is no reason to suppose that Chris would do any better.”
The bigger point though is that Chris improved after his series to the point he could put up some of the moves that otherwise only Suzanne and Matt can. He could stay close to Ray on the skating, and may be able to do equivalent tricks and bigger lifts. As with Suzanne, it then comes down to routines and whether people really like Ray's speed or prefer a better routine or bigger tricks. They may even prefer Hayley doing something funny, or Beth with a show story.
The advantage of having Chris, and/or Mathew or Matt L, there, would be that there would be a proper male competition. Its largely Robin hyperbole, but his claim was there to be disproved that actually Matthew W and Matt L were better skaters. More convincingly, we have actually seen chris do bigger lifts.
The disadvantage is that if they had put 3 more top males in, and Clare Buckfield, who can do more than 3 of the females who made it, there would have been so many good contestants competing for the vote - that it would have been random, and pretty meaningless, who got it.