Originally Posted by ursula321:
“I guessed that she was dead but that was more to do with the decor of flat being really old fashioned. It was sad story but filmed and told really well. ”
The showing of the Andrea Bocelli CD gave it away (link it to the song and you are there).
It was fine as a piece of drama, but one of the more obvious twists of the series (as a Lost fan, this story structure is very familiar; used in several seasons there). Especially the skipping in time between scenes is always a good pointer for this.