Originally Posted by Roscoe Barnes:
“Perhaps disaster is a bit strong - but like someone else mentioned they don't try and fix the things that aren't working and plod on regardless hoping viewers will watch which clearly isn't happening again. It's now fallen every week since the fourth Blind Auditions show - a very worrying trend indeed especially considering it was really supposed to grow in the earlier stages which didn't happen like the previous two years.”
Sorry to carry this on but the same argument can be made with boot camp on The X Factor given whenever we see the ratings for that, and they're down on the auditions, we hear that it's because "Boot Camp never rates well". The audience have already come back for the auditions on two occasions, it is clearly the most popular part of the series and if it rates as well as it does (and continues to do so), who cares? Much like my dad enjoys watching the auditions for The X Factor but doesn't give a toss about the rest of the series.
The Voice gets eight extremely popular episodes that win their slot and four or five that maybe don't but are still highly competitive and outperform everything else on BBC1 that night. Doesn't sound a disaster to me. Sounds like The X Factor.
Originally Posted by Pizzatheaction:
“Takeaway is a diificult watch because it's so stop/start, and not just because of all the commercial breaks, but because of all the little segments which don't seem to link together in any way.”
I always watch Takeaway on Sunday as a recording, because of the adverts which I find irritating in a way I don't with other shows on commercial TV, and also in case one of them dies during Ant vs Dec. I enjoy it, I thought NTV with Dick Spatsley was a lot of fun this weekend, and they can mount a spectacle. Because as mentioned, it's got an enormous budget.
Noel used to say that one of the things you had to do on light entertainment was have a format where the mechanics weren't obvious to the viewer, so they didn't predict everything that was going to happen next. But maybe viewers prefer that kind of thing now.
Originally Posted by iaindb:
“BBC2 should be aiming for innovation and originality and pushing the boundaries and those programmes aren't necessarily going to attract a lot of viewers (particularly in an age when viewers can have as many as 200+ channels to choose). But that doesn't mean those programmes aren't very good programmes or don't deserve to be made.
It has been suggested that the BBC are sticking with some of the programmes because of competition from Sky; because the BBC fear losing the talent to Sky. And Sky remain willing to produce home-grown programmes even though many of them don't rate very highly in the overnights even by Sky's lower expectations. And they do that because the best of these programmes, such as Moone Boy, enhance their reputation. Just as programmes like Stewart Lee's Comedy Vehicle and Inside No 9 will enhance the reputation of BBC Comedy.”
Brilliant post, exactly right. The fact Sky are committing to this kind of thing despite low ratings illustrates how valued these shows are to their audience and why it's certainly important BBC2 continue with them. It's important to remember that they are doing well in relative terms. Fist of Fun was getting about three million in 1995 and that was when the vast majority of people had only four channels, and in its 9pm slot the opposition was the news, an ITV drama and something on C4. Didn't like the ITV drama and didn't want to watch the news? A 50/50 chance you'd go for that. These days with umpteen channels for everyone to choose from, and later in the evening, Stewart Lee is getting about a third of the audience he had then which I think is pretty good going. Amazing it even does that well.
Originally Posted by Brekkie:
“The thing is the likes of Father Ted only grew into big hits thanks to repeats. New episodes might have got the plum 9.30pm slot in between Friends and Frasier, along with a few other sitcoms at the time, but you'd also find previous series repeated there too - and C4 doesn't give it's own shows the luxury of flagship repeat slots anymore. I'm sure The IT Crowd would have been far bigger than it was had it been repeated better.”
Well, you have the ten trillion repeats on E4 which clearly help out shows like The Inbetweeners. A bit topical given we were talking about Family Guy because of course that didn't grow on BBC3 because of primetime screenings, it was thanks to the umpteen late night repeats.
I don't know if Father Ted was helped out by repeats at the time, the first series was only repeated once, on Saturday nights, before the second series began. What helped that was C4 sticking with it and promoting it. In fact the Friday 9.30 slot was a bit overrated, I know when Spaced was in there it was fifth out of the five channels, and I think the same has been true with Peep Show and The IT Crowd in more recent times. They were never rating brilliantly and the latter two dipped under a million on occasions. But obviously they're now much-loved series - thanks to their loyal audience. Ricky Gervais says a load of crap but there is something on how he says he wanted to make a million people's favourite programme, not eight million people's eighth favourite programme.