Although Suzanne has been the better skater so far, Kyran was the better tonight

Yep.....best decision the judges has made so far....mistakes are costly Suzanne....and so is being cocky too!!!!

Kyran was better in the skate off than Suzanne

------------------------------------------------------------------

Yes he was. Judges got it right

How was she being cocky

I agree Kyran was better in the skate off but it's a shame to see Suzanne go. I thought she had the potential to be in the final.

Based on the skate off I do believe the right person was saved.

I agree that Kyran deserved to be saved, and Suzanne has always been my favourite.
I was sorry to see her go, but how she was being cocky?

She was a victim of the team challenge. I doubt she would have been in the skate off from 2nd on the leaderboard which is where she should have been if it wasn't for the team 'lets muck up the scoreboard' farce. Beth ending up bottom would have won her a fair few votes (and I think she is pretty popular anyway) but Suzanne ending up mid table was a travesty.

Was Kyran better in the skate off? His skate wasn't flawless either, the over the head trick was particularly ropey so it could have gone either way.

Yeah she doesn't even have a c*ck????

When a skate off is close any mistakes made are rightly punished so it was definitely the right decision.

Who would have predicted after her 1st performance that she would have been the first champion to go? Was really expecting Beth to be in the skate off but thrilled she was saved & really hope she finishes as the top girl.

I think it might've been Sam vs Kyran in the skate off without the team challenge. This is why I hate the team challenge, it just mucks up the leaderboard and allows a weaker skater to move higher up the leaderboard. I do think Kyran surviving over Suzanne was right but I'm sorry to see her go.

What I don't get is that because Suzanne made mistakes in her Skate Off performance, they didn't save her. But Matt Lapinskas from last year made mistakes in his Skate Off performance, they saved him.

Yeah I'm gutted Suzanne was in the skate off to begin with, she was definitely one of my favourites, and when at her best is one of the few who can come close to Ray, but the judges do stick by judging on the skate off, so out of the two performances it was only fair she went.

I don't like that the group performance has such a big impact on the scores. Maybe they should get an extra point or two so it doesn't mean the winning team will definitely be the top 3 on the leaderboard. Had the team challenge not happened, I don't believe Suzanne would have been in the skate off in the first place.

Suzanne made mistakes in previous skate offs yet was saved. Tonight was the right decision imo.

But this was the first time Suzanne had ever been in the Skate Off.

What? She has never been in a skate off until tonight.

Thought this was her 1st?

Anyways it was the right decision but as Natalian said she was mainly a victim of the stupid team challenge, like the duel it only benefits the weaker skaters.

As the saying goes two wrongs don't make a right. Matt should have gone when he made those mistakes just like Suzanne did tonight.

It tells me that Matt was one of their favourites so they wanted to keep him in. This series, Ray and Hayley are their favourites and because Suzanne obviously isn't either of them, they got rid of her.

It means the judges learnt from their mistakes and did the right thing this time.

That is the purpose of the skate off, other performances dont count, all on that. Kyran was better and deserved to be unanimously saved by the judges.

The argument last year was that although Matt made an obvious mistake, the difference in the difficulty and quality of the skate off performances overall meant that even with a deduction for the mistake, Matt should still have won.

Personally, I have the same feeling about the skate off tonight. Suzanne's mistake might have been glaringly obvious but Kyran was by no means flawless and I can't say that I was blown away by either of them.

Ray & Hayley were not in the skate off!

Kyran bettered Suzannes performance in the skate off so was deservedly saved ...nothing to do with favourites tonight.

I know that. I didn't say they were. I just meant that if either of them HAD BEEN in the Skate Off and had given the performance that Suzanne gave tonight, I think they would have saved them. That's what I was trying to say.

I do agree with what you're saying and I do think the judges do play favourites and I think that they have been especially harsh on Beth this series, but I do think that tonight's result was fair based on the skate off and I do honestly think that if Suzanne had performed that routine as good as she has done previously that they would have saved her 100%. It was the team challenge that put Suzanne in danger not the judges.

I was no fan of Matt Lapinskas but he was head & shoulders above Shayne Ward so I think it was right he was saved. Suzanne & Kyran were more evenly matched so understandable that he was saved when Suzanne made errors.