• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Doctor Who
Doctor Who Companion Hurt and Heal Game
<<
<
14 of 15
>>
>
Jethryk
08-04-2014
Originally Posted by lotrjw:
“OK so if Clara goes then you would be Hurting Ian?

I so wish this end game had been set up in such a way that, first you Hurt the 3 you least liked once each and then second that when one had gone that you Hurt the two you least liked once each, then finally with just two left you voted 2 twice for the 1 you least liked!”

I dunno seems like its going to the wire. Anyone's game.
lotrjw
08-04-2014
Originally Posted by Jethryk:
“I dunno seems like its going to the wire. Anyone's game.”

Thats true its gone way off what I predicted last Friday! and they are all so close still!

Oh and you could post soon(or now or whatever?), it will be interesting seeing the dynamic after your post!
Satmanager
08-04-2014
Originally Posted by Jethryk:
“How quickly can you revote in this?”

You can vote every 12 hours - that is twice a day.
Satmanager
08-04-2014
Originally Posted by lotrjw:
“OK so if Clara goes then you would be Hurting Ian?

I so wish this end game had been set up in such a way that, first you Hurt the 3 you least liked once each and then second that when one had gone that you Hurt the two you least liked once each, then finally with just two left you voted 2 twice for the 1 you least liked!”

I wish you had mentioned something about this when I mentioned how I was going to setup the game at the beginning. I could have done something with it then. I'm just not the type to change horses in mid stream after starting the game as it wouldn't be fair. I will make changes to speed up the game but not to make changes of how the game is played.
The_Judge_
08-04-2014
Originally Posted by Satmanager:
“I wish you had mentioned something about this when I mentioned how I was going to setup the game at the beginning. I could have done something with it then. I'm just not the type to change horses in mid stream after starting the game as it wouldn't be fair. I will make changes to speed up the game but not to make changes of how the game is played.”

Leave it as it is please, I'm not sure it's going the way i want it to in terms of who may win, but that's how games are , i like the consistency (and simplicity) of these rules.
lotrjw
08-04-2014
Originally Posted by Satmanager:
“I wish you had mentioned something about this when I mentioned how I was going to setup the game at the beginning. I could have done something with it then. I'm just not the type to change horses in mid stream after starting the game as it wouldn't be fair. I will make changes to speed up the game but not to make changes of how the game is played.”

I didnt think of it at the time its only after seeing how this has turned out, re the end game bit as its new, that I now see what would be the better option.

Like I said earlier though, I would like to do a new Doctor's game when this is finished (which shouldnt start till 5 days after this has finished at The_Judge's request).
When that starts it will use your format of having decades for categories and a winners game and the winners game should be done the way I have now realised would work better!
The_Judge_
08-04-2014
Use 2 HURTS / NO HEALS (May split Hurts) - 12 HOURS BETWEEN PLAYS

Ian Chesterton 7 HURT
Sarah Jane Smith 8
Clara Oswald 7

ELIMINATED:

Tegan Jovanka 07/04/2014

Nice to know other people are hurting Sarah too
lotrjw
08-04-2014
Originally Posted by The_Judge_:
“Leave it as it is please, I'm not sure it's going the way i want it to in terms of who may win, but that's how games are , i like the consistency (and simplicity) of these rules.”

Its not changing for this game, but the winners game on the next Doctor's game will.
We could just say that instead of allowing people to choose whether they split the hurts that that part is decided for them, but no more than 2 hurts for the whole winners game.
So when there is more than two still in the winners game you have to split your hurts, but if there is only two left you cant split your hurts unless you are taking your choice below 1!
That might be funny though if the two left are down to 1 point each and then we would have to say no splitting then!
lotrjw
08-04-2014
Originally Posted by The_Judge_:
“Nice to know other people are hurting Sarah too ”

Im currently trying to keep Sarah and Ian down to as low or lower than Clara!
Barracute
08-04-2014
Use 2 HURTS / NO HEALS (May split Hurts) - 12 HOURS BETWEEN PLAYS

Ian Chesterton 6 HURT
Sarah Jane Smith 8
Clara Oswald 6 HURT

ELIMINATED:

Tegan Jovanka 07/04/2014
lotrjw
08-04-2014
Originally Posted by Barracute:
“Use 2 HURTS / NO HEALS (May split Hurts) - 12 HOURS BETWEEN PLAYS

Ian Chesterton 6 HURT
Sarah Jane Smith 8
Clara Oswald 6 HURT

ELIMINATED:

Tegan Jovanka 07/04/2014”

Ah now we know who your favourite is
Jethryk
08-04-2014
Use 2 HURTS / NO HEALS (May split Hurts) - 12 HOURS BETWEEN PLAYS

Ian Chesterton 6
Sarah Jane Smith 8
Clara Oswald 4 HURT

ELIMINATED:

Tegan Jovanka 07/04/2014
Satmanager
09-04-2014
Use 2 HURTS / NO HEALS (May split Hurts) - 12 HOURS BETWEEN PLAYS

Ian Chesterton 4 HURT
Sarah Jane Smith 8
Clara Oswald 4

ELIMINATED:

Tegan Jovanka 07/04/2014
brotonsbaby
09-04-2014
Use 2 HURTS / NO HEALS (May split Hurts) - 12 HOURS BETWEEN PLAYS

Ian Chesterton 4
Sarah Jane Smith 8
Clara Oswald 2 HURT

ELIMINATED:

Tegan Jovanka 07/04/2014
The_Judge_
09-04-2014
Use 2 HURTS / NO HEALS (May split Hurts) - 12 HOURS BETWEEN PLAYS

Ian Chesterton 4
Sarah Jane Smith 6 HURT
Clara Oswald 2

ELIMINATED:

Tegan Jovanka 07/04/2014
lotrjw
09-04-2014
Use 2 HURTS / NO HEALS (May split Hurts) - 12 HOURS BETWEEN PLAYS

Ian Chesterton 4
Sarah Jane Smith 4 HURT
Clara Oswald 2

ELIMINATED:

Tegan Jovanka 07/04/2014
Jethryk
09-04-2014
Use 2 HURTS / NO HEALS (May split Hurts) - 12 HOURS BETWEEN PLAYS

Ian Chesterton 4
Sarah Jane Smith 4
Clara Oswald 0 Hurt

ELIMINATED:

Tegan Jovanka 07/04/2014
Clara Oswald 09/04/2014
lotrjw
09-04-2014
LOL who would have predicted that! Clara was top in the main game!
Satmanager
09-04-2014
Use 2 HURTS / NO HEALS (May split Hurts) - 12 HOURS BETWEEN PLAYS

Ian Chesterton 2 HURT
Sarah Jane Smith 4

ELIMINATED:

Tegan Jovanka 07/04/2014
Clara Oswald 09/04/2014

TODAY SHOULD FINSH THE GAME.
lotrjw
09-04-2014
Originally Posted by Satmanager:
“TODAY SHOULD FINSH THE GAME.”

Yes true!

...and 5 days later...

--------------------------------------------------------------

Oh and what we end up with this combination:

Ian 1
Sarah 1

what would we do then?
its quite possible as it would only take someone hurting Sarah once and then someone hurting both and they would both be at 1 point each!
Satmanager
09-04-2014
Originally Posted by lotrjw:
“Yes true!

...and 5 days later...

--------------------------------------------------------------

Oh and what we end up with this combination:

Ian 1
Sarah 1

what would we do then?
its quite possible as it would only take someone hurting Sarah once and then someone hurting both and they would both be at 1 point each!”

The person taking the last turn would use one of his/her points and apply it to the companion that they wish to eliminate. At that point the game is over. The other point is not used. Points are used sequentially, not simultaneously.
lotrjw
09-04-2014
Originally Posted by Satmanager:
“The person taking the last turn would use one of his/her points and apply it to the companion that they wish to eliminate. At that point the game is over. The other point is not used. Points are used sequentially, not simultaneously.”

Ah right so they would only use one point and the other one would be null and void, as otherwise the second point would kill the winner! who wins by one point!
Satmanager
09-04-2014
Originally Posted by lotrjw:
“Ah right so they would only use one point and the other one would be null and void, as otherwise the second point would kill the winner! who wins by one point!”

That is correct. We can't have you kill your own winner now can we.
Satmanager
09-04-2014
Use 2 HURTS / NO HEALS (May split Hurts)

Ian Chesterton 2 HURT
Sarah Jane Smith 4

ELIMINATED:

Tegan Jovanka 07/04/2014
Clara Oswald 09/04/2014

TODAY SHOULD FINISH THE GAME. YOU MAY TAKE YOUR 2ND MOVE FOR THE DAY AT ANY TIME AS LONG AS YOU ONLY USE 2 MOVES IN A 24 HOUR PERIOD.
Jethryk
09-04-2014
deleted
<<
<
14 of 15
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map