My thoughts would be

Performance

Ray 5
Hayley 4
Sam 3
Beth 2
Kyran 1

Technical Ability

Ray 5
Beth 4
Kyran 3
Sam 2
Hayley 1

Added together my scores would be

Ray 10
Beth 6
Hayley & Sam 5
Kyran 4

What do you think?

Performance:
Ray 5
Hayley 4
Beth 3
Sam 2
Kyran 1

Technical Ability:
Ray 5
Beth 4
Kyran 3
Sam 2
Hayley 1

Overall:
Ray 10
Beth 7
Hayley 5
Sam & Kyran 4

Performance:

Ray 5
Hayley 4
Sam 3
Beth 2
Kyran 1

Technical ability

Ray 5
Sam 4
Beth 3
Kyran 2
Hayley 1

Totals:

Ray 10
Sam 7
Hayley and Beth 5
Kyran 3

I'd like the end result to be

Ray 1st
Sam 2nd
Beth 3rd

Hayley and Beth balance each other out with performance/technical, but as it's a skating competition, and Hayley is the weakest skater, Beth should finish ahead of her.

To add: If Suzanne was still here, I'd have the end result as:

Ray 1st
Sam/Suzanne 2nd and 3rd (in either order)

Performance
Ray - 5
Hayley - 4
Sam - 3
Beth - 2
Kyran - 1

Technique
Ray - 5
Beth - 4
Kyran - 3
Sam - 2
Hayley - 1

Overall
Ray - 10
Beth - 6
Hayley - 5
Sam - 5
Kyran - 4

Performance

Ray 5
Hayley 4
Beth 3
Sam 2
Kyran 1

Technical Ability

Ray 5
Beth 4
Sam 3
Hayley 2
Kyran 1

Added together my scores would be

Ray 10
Beth 7
Hayley 6
Sam 5
Kyran 2

Performance

Ray 5
Hayley 4
Sam 3
Kyran 2
Beth 1

Technical Ability

Ray 5
Kyran 4
Beth 3
Hayley 2
Sam 1

Added together my scores would be

Ray 10
Hayley 6
Kyran 6
Beth 4
Sam 4

Performance

5. Ray
4. Sam
3. Beth
4. Kyran
5. Hayley (too much dancing on toepicks and arm waving - theres more to performance than that!)

Technique

5. Ray
4. Beth
3. Kyran
2. Sam
1. Hayley

Total

10 Ray
7 Beth
6 Sam
5 Kyran
2 Hayley

Performance
5-Ray
4-Beth
3-Hayley
2-Sam
1-Kyran

Technique
5-Ray
4-Beth
3-Kyran
2-Hayley
1-Sam

Total:
10:Ray
8:Beth
5:Hayley
4:Kyran
3:Sam

Performance
5 - Ray
4 - Hayley
3 - Sam
2 - Beth
1 - Kyran

Technique
5 - Ray
4 - Beth
3 - Sam
2 - Kyran
1 - Hayley

Overall
Ray 10
Beth 6
Sam 6
Hayley 5
Kyran 3