Are the judges using beth been I'll as an excuses to under mark and get her in the skate off.... I still feel they never wanted her to win last year
using beth been ill
Originally Posted by Chloe_Beads:
“Are the judges using beth been I'll as an excuses to under mark and get her in the skate off.... I still feel they never wanted her to win last year”
“Are the judges using beth been I'll as an excuses to under mark and get her in the skate off.... I still feel they never wanted her to win last year”
Absolute rubbish!
As if they need an excuse...
Yes, because her illness unfortunately means that she lacks energy and precision. They mark on the performance they're shown. Stop being silly.
Originally Posted by rebecca87:
“Yes, because her illness unfortunately means that she lacks energy and precision. They mark on the performance they're shown. Stop being silly.”
“Yes, because her illness unfortunately means that she lacks energy and precision. They mark on the performance they're shown. Stop being silly.”
If they mark on performance then why didn't they pick up on Hayley's cock up of a solo performance where she proved how much of a crap skater she is without Dan to cling onto?
Originally Posted by Vodka_Drinka:
“If they mark on performance then why didn't they pick up on Hayley's cock up of a solo performance where she proved how much of a crap skater she is without Dan to cling onto?”
“If they mark on performance then why didn't they pick up on Hayley's cock up of a solo performance where she proved how much of a crap skater she is without Dan to cling onto?
”
Clearly they did as it got the worst score of the night
Originally Posted by Vodka_Drinka:
“They didn't want her to win last year and did everything in their power to stop it.”
“They didn't want her to win last year and did everything in their power to stop it.”
Neither were they gracious when she won
Originally Posted by Tissy:
“Neither were they gracious when she won”
“Neither were they gracious when she won
”
I completely agree they were awful to her last year imo she is the best female celeb they have had on the show, although Sjuzanne was good in her series! Beth is never given credit for anything!
Originally Posted by Tissy:
“Neither were they gracious when she won”
“Neither were they gracious when she won
”
I forgot about that, didn't they not clap her or something like that when she was announced as the winner?
Originally Posted by Vodka_Drinka:
“I forgot about that, didn't they not clap her or something like that when she was announced as the winner?”
“I forgot about that, didn't they not clap her or something like that when she was announced as the winner?”
Three of them managed to put their hands together in a fashion Jason just sat there looking disgusted at the result
Originally Posted by Vodka_Drinka:
“I forgot about that, didn't they not clap her or something like that when she was announced as the winner?”
“I forgot about that, didn't they not clap her or something like that when she was announced as the winner?”
They all sat there with a face on them! Didn't stand for her or even applaud her after the initial result. Once they realised the camera was still panning to them occasionally, they started clapping... still with a face on them, though.
Robin then responded on Twitter to all the comments about the judges behaviour, stating that he believes Matt still should have won.
The way he said it really annoyed me at the time, but I've forgotten exactly how it was put. Basically, "public got it wrong, Beth didn't deserve it", and he really tried to take her win away from her. I was furious, to be honest. A supposed grown man acting like a big baby because his chosen one never won - it was pathetic.
Obviously, they're desperate for her not to repeat her win this year.
Originally Posted by Tissy:
“Three of them managed to put their hands together in a fashion Jason just sat there looking disgusted at the result”
“Three of them managed to put their hands together in a fashion Jason just sat there looking disgusted at the result
”
Well he can be a nasty little man, he certainly was when Beth won, plain rude!
Ray was always going to win they will make sure and they want hailey 2nd IMO .... beth didn't look much different tonight in terms of peformamce but her skating was the same as ever and didn't need the judges ranging on about her been out of sorts all the time ... I call beth and Hailey in the skate off??;
I don't want that bottom 2 just think that is what will happen but as soon as they get beth in the bottom they will send her home I'm sure
What really annoys me about this is that with any other celeb being ill they usually get sympathy and encouragement (and some get slightly inflated marks), whereas Beth got a grudging 'hope you feel better soon' and they penalized her even more than they should have.
Originally Posted by Chloe_Beads:
“Ray was always going to win they will make sure and they want hailey 2nd IMO .... beth didn't look much different tonight in terms of peformamce but her skating was the same as ever and didn't need the judges ranging on about her been out of sorts all the time ... I call beth and Hailey in the skate off??;”
“Ray was always going to win they will make sure and they want hailey 2nd IMO .... beth didn't look much different tonight in terms of peformamce but her skating was the same as ever and didn't need the judges ranging on about her been out of sorts all the time ... I call beth and Hailey in the skate off??;”
Ray was always going to win because he is by far the best. They don't need to 'make sure' he wins. He will win because he deserves to win, not because of any perceived underhand tactics on the judges' part.
Originally Posted by lulu g:
“Ray was always going to win because he is by far the best. They don't need to 'make sure' he wins. He will win because he deserves to win, not because of any perceived underhand tactics on the judges' part.”
“Ray was always going to win because he is by far the best. They don't need to 'make sure' he wins. He will win because he deserves to win, not because of any perceived underhand tactics on the judges' part.”
This ^^^
Originally Posted by Tissy:
“Three of them managed to put their hands together in a fashion Jason just sat there looking disgusted at the result”
“Three of them managed to put their hands together in a fashion Jason just sat there looking disgusted at the result
”
And not one of them stood up.
I'm going to stop putting an opinion in here .... its just a bitchy place to be ... in other topics you can have a discussion but on here you just get shot down for what ever you say.. I didn't make comment about the ability of any one just that the judges will make sure ray wins as they didn't get the winner they wanted last year ( he is the better skater ) but they won't let a champion be crowned they dony want with out a fight ... IMO.... I expressed that I thaught beth can be unnder marked but last night they used it as an excuse to attack her performance and mark lower than they needed to (she hasn't got the same performance as others but is a better skater than 1 or 2.... ) on level of performance for me beth will always be bottom of the final 4 we have but in skills IMO is second to ray when given the right piece to skate ... with hailey 4th
Beth definitely under-performed compared with what we all know she's capable of. The judges couldn't ignore that, or judge her as if she'd skated better.
They were perhaps a bit mean with some of the scoring, as she still did a lot, and had some tricky lifts and moves in there, but there are just champions left, so they have to mark against high expectations.
They were perhaps a bit mean with some of the scoring, as she still did a lot, and had some tricky lifts and moves in there, but there are just champions left, so they have to mark against high expectations.
