• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • Past Reality Shows
  • Dancing On Ice: All Stars
How is Beth still in?!
<<
<
1 of 2
>>
>
iMatt_101
23-02-2014
No way did Kyran deserve to go tonight! Beth's routines are so dull every week, how the hell has she never been in a skate off? What do the public see in her?
jeanoj
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by iMatt_101:
“No way did Kyran deserve to go tonight! Beth's routines are so dull every week, how the hell has she never been in a skate off? What do the public see in her?”

I agree - I think she gets the votes because she is an "Olympian". She should have gone by now. Kyran and Sam both had fantastic skate offs tonight - they should both still be there.
Melody.ExE
23-02-2014
She's treated so badly by the judges, undermarked week upon week, and not given any credit for any of the complex skating she does.

I voted for her tonight because she I thought she deserved more than that. (And partially as a retaliation against the overmarking of Hayley)
Stuart25
23-02-2014
How is Beth still in?

The public are voting for her.
StarryNight1983
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by iMatt_101:
“No way did Kyran deserve to go tonight! Beth's routines are so dull every week, how the hell has she never been in a skate off? What do the public see in her?”

You try skating with the flu!!

At least Beth can skate and skate well!
yellowlabbie
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by jeanoj:
“I agree - I think she gets the votes because she is an "Olympian". She should have gone by now. Kyran and Sam both had fantastic skate offs tonight - they should both still be there.”

Yes, Beth is one of my favourites but she was disappointing tonight, Kyran and Sam were better than her but it's the votes that count
Chris1347
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by Melody.ExE:
“She's treated so badly by the judges, undermarked week upon week, and not given any credit for any of the complex skating she does.

I voted for her tonight because she I thought she deserved more than that. (And partially as a retaliation against the overmarking of Hayley)”

Exactly! Melody, she is still in because she is a great skater who is given no credit for her skills by the judges! The public can see straight through that, personally I thought Kyran's skate off was better than Sam's
sorrell
23-02-2014
Beth isn't a bad skater, but I don't think she's as good as some of the others, however, she is very likeable and Sam isn't, I think this is one of the main reasons she remains out of the skate off every week.
yellowlabbie
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by StarryNight1983:
“You try skating with the flu!!

At least Beth can skate and skate well!”

She didn't have the flu, she said herself that she had a virus. There is a big difference, if she had flu she wouldn't be able to stand up, never mind skate.
Reserved
23-02-2014
She's a great skater and deserves to be at least the top female. Give me routines that lack a little in performance (i.e. Beth's) over routines that lack in everything but performance (i.e. Hayley) any day.

Hayley might as well stand off the ice and pull those faces - not like there's any difference than when she's stood on it, anyway.
4troy7
23-02-2014
I find her overrated sick or not sick she never wows me .
tawny
23-02-2014
The public like Beth - I'm glad she is still in she is a great skater. sam should have gone - he is full of himself
natalian
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by iMatt_101:
“No way did Kyran deserve to go tonight! Beth's routines are so dull every week, how the hell has she never been in a skate off? What do the public see in her?”

Personally, I think Kyran should have gone weeks ago and I don't know what anyone sees in him. I think he is so dull every week.
Scorpio2
23-02-2014
She is in because the judges constantly undermark her and she is much better than they make out.
However us viewers are not fooled by them and that is why we vote.
StarryNight1983
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“She didn't have the flu, she said herself that she had a virus. There is a big difference, if she had flu she wouldn't be able to stand up, never mind skate.”

WHATEVER she had she was very poorly and I would love to see the people moaning about her go out and skate when they are that poorly!!
tabithakitten
23-02-2014
Beth's clearly popular but I do think there's an element of "Let's stick it to the judges" in her vote at the minute.

I hope it doesn't carry all the way through to the result though. She's better than Hayley but not as good as Ray or Sam imo.
yellowlabbie
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by StarryNight1983:
“WHATEVER she had she was very poorly and I would love to see the people moaning about her go out and skate when they are that poorly!!”

I like Beth but I was just making a point that she didn't have flu.
camy934
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by iMatt_101:
“No way did Kyran deserve to go tonight! Beth's routines are so dull every week, how the hell has she never been in a skate off? What do the public see in her?”

Because she's amazing and always undermarked
yellowlabbie
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by Scorpio2:
“She is in because the judges constantly undermark her and she is much better than they make out.
However us viewers are not fooled by them and that is why we vote.”

Maybe so but the 3 men were better than her tonight and they are better skaters than Beth.
StarryNight1983
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“I like Beth but I was just making a point that she didn't have flu.”

That's fine - I thought she said flu but I must of been hearing things
Tiggergirl
23-02-2014
Because she is a fantastic skater and thankfully the GBP recognise that she is talented and are voting for her each week. I personally am sick of the overperformed twee that keeps getting churned out in the show and lack of actual skating being mostly conveniently ignored in some cases and it's nice to see some actual technical skill being applied would just be nice to see the judges especially those meant to recognise and acknowledge the skating skill actually giving her some credit for it but it seems with Robin in particular if you aren't male then you can't possibly have any discernible talent.

The public are obviously voting for her because they are liking watching her and I hope she goes on to the final and wins (although that might be a bit much to ask)
natalian
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“Maybe so but the 3 men were better than her tonight and they are better skaters than Beth.”

Perhaps they were tonight but the public don't have to judge it just on tonight. Over the course of history I would say that Beth is a better skater than Kyran (definitely) and Sam (probably)....but then I would have said that Suzanne was better than all three of them and she was the first ex champion out

As I think Beth has been better overall, I would have no problem voting for her (and did so) although she isn't my favourite - that has to be Ray as any other result would be a travesty.
jeanoj
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“She didn't have the flu, she said herself that she had a virus. There is a big difference, if she had flu she wouldn't be able to stand up, never mind skate.”

Exactly!
norbitonite
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by natalian:
“Personally, I think Kyran should have gone weeks ago and I don't know what anyone sees in him. I think he is so dull every week.”

I would've agreed with you before tonight's show, but I really enjoyed his skates this evening - particularly in the SO, where I thought he was better to watch than Sam, whose Riverdance was a bit ragged.
Reserved
23-02-2014
Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“Maybe so but the 3 men were better than her tonight and they are better skaters than Beth.”

I disagree. Kyran's first (couple) routine was dull. I had to force myself to pay attention to it and Sam's just a cheap version of Ray.

Beth brings something different to the table with her lifts and tricks, and overall, thoughout the series, she's been a much stronger skater than Kyran and Sam.

Her solo wasn't good because they gave her a routine she had to "perform" - her weakest skill. Should've given her a piece of music that could show off her skating; everyone else got a solo skate that suits them.
<<
<
1 of 2
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map