Originally Posted by don roberto:
“I'm afraid I just don't get this rather childish "the judges don't like/want Beth to win". They are experts while I doubt many, if any posters here are. So, it's down to perception and who people like often for reasons quite unconnected with performance in the show.
I have said elsewhere that I'm not a fan of Ray and never have been but, I cannot dispute that he is by far the best. I'm sure Beth is a nice humble person but, in my opinion, is the weakest because, as the judges say, she finds it hard to perform. I cannot dispute she has mastered skating skills but in a robotic and soulless way. This is what the judges have said.
As to Phillip's comments I suspect he too is less than happy that "his" show has been axed. I hardly think he is expert enough to challenge the judges decisions anymore than are people who post here.
All that said, if Beth wins then good luck to her but as this is the end of what has become a rather tedious show it will soon be forgotten.”
I think the mere fact that Chris felt the need to speak out in Beth's defence says that all the so - called "Beth defenders " are 100% right in what they have been saying about her lack of any really contructive criticism, bitchy remarks, little praise and low marks.
Chris (and Robin for that matter) is himself a brilliant skater who has won European, World and Olympic medals and has choreographed ice shows for years - I think he is eminenently qualified to say what he did about the judging over this series. He knows what a good performance looks like - and given the fact his choreography experience is for ice shows - definitely makes him more qualified to judge than Jason who only has stage experience, and definitely more than Ashley who was only a member of a girlband.