|
||||||||
Top 10 performance discussion (spoilers) |
![]() |
|
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|
|
#1 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Dec 2012
Posts: 7,374
|
Top 10 performance discussion (spoilers)
Hi all, how did everyone find this week's performances? My thoughts:
MK 3/10 - started off nice then she got pitchy and just completely lacked any sort of enthusiasm...she's so my pick to go this week Dexter 5/10 - can this guy be any more generic? Jena 5/10 - from her excellent Decode performance to this was seriously disappointing...her vocals were verging on screeching at some points..definitely a B2 contender Alex 8/10 - hate this song, but I really enjoyed his version...JLo likening him to Buddy Holly was spot on I thought, really nice. Malaya 8/10 - again don't really like the song but wow her vocals were so spot on this week and she really felt the song...nice to see someone improving! Caleb 7/10 - personally a step down from Skyfall but still nice...it just felt a bit 1 dimensional to me in that it was just belt belt belt... Cj 1/10 - I have never heard a more pitchy performance before...if he is not B2 after this I will be shocked...awful just awful. Jessica 6/10 - don't particularly like the song again but felt like her vocals didn't suit this and that she was singing in the wrong key (again) but really like her tone and her style Majesty 9/10 - the one performance which i keep watching again and again, it was just so beautiful, the way she really felt the song and hit all these beautiful notes with that gorgeous tone gave me goosebumps - so glad she's back on track. Sam 7/10 - big improvement on last week's dire energy drain performance...this had a bit of life to it and was an enjoyable performance. Top 3 for me: 1) Majesty, 2) Mallaya, 3) Alex Bottom 3 for me: 3) Dexter, 2) MK, 1) CJ Bottom 3 tomorrow: Jena, MK, CJ (MK to go) What were your thoughts? |
|
|
|
|
Please sign in or register to remove this advertisement.
|
|
|
#2 |
|
Inactive Member
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 1,995
|
MK......2/10........What the hell?
Dexter........5/10......Agreed. Needs to step it up. Jena..........8/10........She was amazing. Don't know why you didn't like her Alex........8/10.......One of the best tonight, very good song. He Is on a role Malaya.......9/10.....Best, Best, Best. WOW!!!!. and she didn't even show off with her voice Caleb......6/10......Predictable. But still a good vocal. He just needs to pick better songs CJ........1/10.........AWFUL. Jessica.......7/10.......Something sounded weird, but overall, a really big step up from last week. Majesty..........8/10.........SOOOOOO much better than last week. Great performance! Sam......7/10........Again, a big step up from last week. It suited his voice sooo much. Could of done with a much better song, but thats just me My Top 3.......1) Malaya.....2) Alex.....3) Jena My Bottom 3........8) Dexter.....9) MK.....10) CJ I want CJ to go, but I think it would be Mk |
|
|
|
|
|
#3 |
|
Forum Member
Join Date: Sep 2011
Posts: 7,744
|
I don't know who's gone yet.
I will just comment on a couple of people to keep it a bit shorter Alex - I agree with you both. 8/10. He is very natural and he is different. Possible winner. Majesty - Still my favourite but she has still not topped the Coldplay song in her first ever appearance. But I think she will. I love everything about her. The only tiny criticism I would make if I were lucky enough to meet her is to mention her eyes. Yes her eyes. Most performances see her looking up, and to one side, as though she is telling us a story, and is visualising the scene. It is very cute but she is overdoing it a bit for me. When she notices the camera tracking her and looks into it she is surprisingly beautiful. I suspect she will win. 8.5 out of 10. Other observations: The bass player in the house band "taps his feet". Yes, both his feet at the same time. And doesn't fall over. The judges are still impressing me. Especially Harry. Have you noticed that his exact thoughts about pretty much everything, especially the little glitches, and the people he is less keen on, are written all over his face? Listening to the judges is great telly. The comments about Artistry should be irritating but they are not because for some reason they don't sound like cliches. They sound like a real conversation the judges would have backstage.. |
|
|
|
![]() |
|
All times are GMT. The time now is 14:28.

