Originally Posted by CELT1987:
“Some of the Planet of The Daleks episodes looked sparkly and grainy. Even the opening titles didn't look remastered.”
Thats odd, I will give you that episode 3 might have looked grainy as that was restored from a 16mm B&W print, thats the episode they recovered the colour on.
Not sure if the otheres recovered from NTSC 525, but if they were then reverse standards conversion would have been used, but that wouldnt have made them grainy just lacking a small bit of information with the loss of some lines when originally converted to 525.
Remember that these early episodes were stored in an analogue format until recently (thats the last 10-15 years that they would have been transferred to a digital format) and each time analogue tape gets played it degrades and of course over time it degrades too.
Yes Im sure that digital tape degrades too, but the content wont degrade unless it cant be read.
I would hope that some of the analogue degrading can be cleaned up, but I would think there is only so much cleaning up that can be done and that they will come to a point it cant be improved upon any more.
With the titles, I know they rebuild them from scratch but I would have thought that they would want to keep the look they originally had.