Originally Posted by Bushmills:
“Common ground between you and Andy23 for once (although you're both saying it for different reasons).
The truth is that a significant number of BBC Breakfast viewers WILL budge, but only if ITV gives them a decent alternative. It hasn't managed to actually do that for about five years.”
ITV can get a significant number of viewers at breakfast for launch shows but don't keep them, even then it still doesn't take that many from Breakfast. GMB is far better than Daybreak and is a good alternative. But large numbers watch Breakfast because they like it.
Originally Posted by SamuelW:
“No no no, BBC Breakfast viewers will now not budge. If youve been watching BBC Breakfast for 3+ years, which is 95% of its viewers, why on earth would you suddenly decide to stop watching it and revert to Itv's alternatives which inherently has adverts, phone in competitions, wheel of fortune game, more showbiz news etc? You simply wouldnt - it's common sense. Unless BBC Breakfast becomes really really bad and starts introducing much more gossip/showbiz news and a huge scandal happens, there is no way a viewer of BBC Breakfast will want to tune over to another alternative. Especially if youre an older 60+ yo viewer, the Itv alternative is simply unsatisfactory. The war has been lost, the viewers have moved to the BBC and in this day and age, they arent going to move back. This isnt the 80s we live in with just 3 channels and audiences potentially moving from one to another channel in their droves - its the 2010s - once youre into a habit and routine, you aint gonna budge. Itvs breakfast show is now a lost cause, they can revamp it as many times as they want, they can become a clone of BBC breakfast if they want or be the complete opposite of BBC breakfast, they can go upmarket or downmarket, they can have one sofa or three chairs, they can have two presenters or four, they can have graphics along the bottom or no graphics there - it doesnt matter either way, viewers arent going to switch. The damage has been done.”
Breakfast would need to implode and become EXTREMELY shit for large numbers to ditch it. It's still a good programme with a good mix of stories and personalities. GMB has some good journalism but they can't shake their tabloid roots and bung in celebrity drivel that drives me away. Then if they make it too serious they will lose the audience that prefers the lighter GMB over BBC Breakfast.
They are stuck between a rock and a hard place. And many of the problems on GMB and ITV at breakfast in general were self inflicted.
They never should have taken on Susanna Reid, signed in the hope she'd bring some BBC Breakfast viewers with her. She may have done but nowhere near enough. They put her front and centre of all the promotional imagery so can't moan if the media fixated on her about the ratings.
A programme that says it's wrong to focus on her looks then does a feature on her making the FHM list.....which they then put on their website and tweet a link to!
Watching Good Morning America, but not closely enough to see that they don't have 4 presenters talking at the start of the show.
Sean Fletcher being billed as a main presenter when he is missing in action for most of the programme.
Treating celebrity fluff as a main headline and story.
None of that appeals to BBC Breakfast viewers but will to an alternative audience.
There is a level of smugness that permeates through the GMB production team on Twitter. They need to stop focusing on Breakfast and do their own show.