I have done this before but I never got round to finishing it and would like to do this in a quicker way.

I'm looking for 4 judges who shall help me to lead our way to what we think is the best doctor who episode.

To start with, each judge + myself (the presenter) shall have a 'Wildcard' episode which they can choose from every doctor who episode ever to go straight through to our semi finals. Then, I will ask (and I know it will take a lot of time) all of our judges to mark every story (not episodes such as Inferno Part 4) out of 10. I will then add the scores up to give a total out of 40. If an episode gets over 25/40 they go through to our knockout round. This knockout round is where I create a Chatzy for our judges to whittle the episodes down to 35 (our 5 wildcards not included). That will give us our 40 semi finalists. Over 5 semi finals there shall be 8 semi finalists in each. It will be then down to YOU out public to decide which 2 episodes from each semi final go through to the final. We will have 10 finalists.

If you would like to judge, just comment. Also comment if you have any questions

Also in the semi finals, if our judges don't like an episode, they can say they have buzzed like BGT judges

Anybody?

I could give it a go

I'd really like to do this. Please, even if it means 3 judges (with me being one of them ahha) yes I'm desperate

I could give it a go but I don't know the classic stories that well.

Just rate the ones you know then and maybe look up synopsis/judge it on episode titles for others?

Thank you for joining

Ok then I can do it

Thank you both for joining it is much appreciated.

Can you also both PM me with an episode you would like to go straight through to the semi finals.

There are still 2 judging places left.

If I don't have my final two judges by 10pm, I will become a judge and we shall only have 3 judges

If there are 3 judges, the minimum total to go through will be 20/30

I shall be the 3rd judge. If anybody says they want to judge by mid-day tomorrow, they may be accepted

I'd love to be the fourth judge, as I'm such a huge fan of Doctor Who, but unfortunately, I am busy during the day and most of the time, cannot use Digital Spy until 5pm at the earliest. The best time for me is between 5pm and 1am. That's when I am on here posting comments. Not constantly between 5pm and 1am, just on/off.

If I were to be a judge, would it require me to be on here a lot?

So we now have our 4 judges:

Doctorwhofancal
Tiggerpooh
Grazemytvaddict
Davrosdodebird

Our judges are currently marking the episodes, I shall post the results as soon as I've got everyones scores.

I seem to recall this being done by the OP at least once before.

Last Summer we went through weeks of 'rounds' with judges and votes, only for the OP to abandon it around the semifinals.

This does seem to form a pattern from the OP, who I believe has a history of starting game threads on this and other forums which are then never completed.

I mean no offence at all, but I am not up for wasting my time yet again.

And I seem to recall you slagging me off last time.

I shall finish this

A) because I want to
B) to prove a point

And also I've found a quicker way for the rounds, so much that the semi finals will probably start this week

Not 'slagging you off' at all, just stating facts.

If you do indeed finish this, then kudos to you. It can be frustrating for people to get involved with something, then be left hanging. I felt it worthwhile to make people aware of what they may be getting into.

Good luck with your game, drwhofancal.

Yes, I do admit that I am bad for continuing games but I would really really like to finish this game.

Thanks

I have just finished my marking.

My lowest score is a 2, my highest is of course a 10

How do I send my results to you, when I have finished marking?

Through PM please

Just done that. You should have my results now.

The minimum total to get to the Chatzy thread is now 28/40

Just replied to your PM's, giving my score for the episode I missed out. Sorry about that! Plus the wildcard.

I'm still awaiting Davros's scores. If I don't have them by 6pm tonight, I will have to make the scores out of 30