Like how can anyone on that square judge max

I didn't feel sorry for him but I understand what you mean.

Phil annoyed me most. He's done MUCH worse. Ruby Allen anyone...:?

Still king Phith exists!

I did kind of during the scene when Phil and Alfie had a go at him.

Few strange reactions from the likes of Phil, given Max wasn't actually doing anything wrong.

I agree. It might not be nice from Ian's point of view, but she was an adult and one who could think for herself.

I did, I was so annoyed with Phil judging him as well. He isn't exactly a bloody saint, is he?

He has killed a man, covered up murders, has been a general **** to people for nearly 2 decades, cheated on people and whole lot of other stuff yet Max is the bad guy for shagging someone who was single.

And he had an affair with Dawn as well. Max was not in a relationship with anyone so he was single.

Yea also thought Lauren's reaction was abit odd. I thought she and the others at the chapel would have got on a lot more shocked when it was revealed.

Yeah, weirdly I did too!

This. Max didn't do anything wrong he didn't cheat on anyone this time. I didn't like Phil's reaction he had an affair with Dawn who was younger than him.

No because Max is old enough and experienced enough to know the consequences of sleeping with someone he probably shouldn't.

However, he and Lucy were both consenting adults and while Ian, Peter, Lauren and Abi would find it a bit weird it's none of anyone elses business.

I kind of did as well actually .

I felt sorry for him. However it is a soap rule that despite everyone else having committed unspeakable crimes, they still stand in judgement on the most minor of offences

Id be scared to show Max any sympathy in case he tried to shag me.

No way I dont feel sorry for him as he slept with Lucy which was very wrong she was young enough to be his daughter that is sick

I agree.

Lucy was an adult who chose to sleep with Max. He didn't force himself on her. For once Max wasn't cheating on anyone and who he sleeps with is his business. It's just unfortunate in this case that the woman he slept with got murdered a few days/weeks later. It's understandable that Ian might want him to stay away from him but Phil had no right to ban him from almost all the square. Who does he think he is?

I agree with last bit defiantly. Its not like Lucy was 15 or 14 she is 20 and also Max was not in a relationship with anyone and neither was Lucy

I agree with you guys and I was sorry for him too.

I'm the complete opposite

I agree with all of this. Maybe Max should of banned Phil from the Car Lot. Imagine if Phil was sleeping with Lucy instead then would anyone ban Phil from the Vic and Caff and everywhere else

Dawn was young enough to be Phil's daughter when he slept with her and he did this when she was with Gary.

Max however slept with a consenting 21 year old.

The only people who have the right to be upset over Max shagging Lucy is her family. Phil has no right at all.

Exactly and what on earth was that garbage about Jake seeing Max with Lucy and then deciding to kill her. What absurd logic.

Did feel a bit sorry for max, but he should have come clean about it when Lucy died and dealt with the consequences all would have been forgiven by now. Now we have to wait another month for all to be forgiven lol

But he didn't cheat on anyone did he and Lucy was 20 so its not like its a crime.

It makes me wonder why Phil was so over the top