Originally Posted by jwire1977:
“A fair number of those settlements are only linked to Glasgow through recent (post war) urban sprawl. And some are tenuous in the extreme.
You can travel from Liverpool to Manchester in a certain direction (loosely following the A580) and barely see a field but few would argue they are the same place.
Small town identity is important to people that live near to a big city. Do people in Bromsgrove, Redditch, Wolverhampton and Walsall consider themselves to be part of Birmingham?”
The Liverpool and Manchester analogy is an over exaduration , I've hardly claimed that Edinburgh should be classed as the Glasgow area.
On the Birmingham analogy, as a resident (or at least future resident) I would describe myself as from Birmingham unless I was to talking to someone outside out of the area. That said Walsall is still legitimately part of the Birmingham area.