Okay, if you could rate out of 10 for each category and for each of them what would it be?

Music:
Judging:
Image:
Current:
Looks:
Voice:

Here's mine:
Tulisa

Music: 3
Judging: 5
Image: 2
Current: 2
Looks: 6
Voice: 4
TOTAL: 20

Cheryl

Music: 6
Judging: 6
Image: 5
Current: 4
Looks: 8
Voice: 2 (check out her cover of Fireflies on Radio 1 Live Lounge awful)
TOTAL: 31

Cheryl Wins.

You?

Here's mine:
Tulisa

Music: 1
Judging: 3
Image: 2
Current: 1
Looks: 3 (those lips and botox )
Voice: 3
TOTAL: 13

Cheryl

Music: 6
Judging: 7
Image: 8
Current: 5
Looks: 9
Voice: 4
TOTAL: 39

Tulisa

Music: 8
Judging: 7
Image: 5
Current: 5
Looks: 7 (I think its wrong to judge looks but she would've been higher without the surgery)
Voice: 7
TOTAL: 39

Cheryl

Music: 6
Judging: 6
Image: 8
Current: 5
Looks: 10
Voice: 4
TOTAL: 39

It's a tie.

Note: I'm not really sure what was meant by current so I gave them both equal scores.

Tulisa:

Music: 0
Judging: 2
Image: 2
Current: ?
Looks: 2
Voice: 3

Cheryl:

Music: 6
Judging: 6
Image: 8
Current: ?
Looks: 9
Voice: 4

Those rating Cheryl's voice above Tulisa's are either deluded or in need of a hearing aid.

Agreed, Neither of them are very good but Cheryl is atrocious and Tulisa is better

You forgot to include a category for 'criminal acts committed'.

oh great, another, 'pitting women against eachother' thread - just what the world needs.

i cant believe cheryls got anything for judging..

she is a vacuous, vacant bint who struggles to form an opinion.

tulisa on the other hand is live, animated. intelligent.

She is scared to be critical of anyone the public like that is probably why, She NEEDS to be loved by as many as possible

She sits on the fence as much as she can. It is the same when she is interviewed. They can't ask her anything she may need to say negative things about so it is all positives for her.

Tulisa:

Music: 5
Judging: 5
Image: 3
Current: 2
Looks: 6
Voice: 4

Cheryl:

Music: 7
Judging: 7
Image: 9
Current: 7
Looks: 9
Voice: 5

Cheryl
Not the best singer but as a person she seems genuine and her music is good

Tulisa
Despite having a better voice, i found her a bit arrogant in that she felt she knew and knew that during her time on The XF, too cock sure of herself and well, her debut album was a disaster.

not the best qualifications then to be a judge!

nah... it doesnt wash with me m8.

Tulisa:

Music: 5
Judging: 8
Image: 3
Current: 2
Looks: 7
Voice: 7

TOTAL: 32

Cheryl:

Music: 8
Judging: 5
Image: 9
Current: 8
Looks: 10
Voice: 8

TOTAL: 48


I think Cheryl has a nicer, warmer tone to her voice, even though she's not as technically capable as Tulisa.

Tulisa is better live, but on CD I prefer Cheryl's vocals.

Tulisa:
Music: 0
Judging: 2
Image: 3
Current: 1
Looks: 7
Voice: 2
=15

Cheryl:
Music: 0
Judging: 1
Image: 6
Current: 1
Looks: 8
Voice: 1
=17

Tbh, musically, they are both steaming piles of shit. I give props to Tulisa because she at least cares about writing her own music, but her personality ruins her. You can take the girl out of the estate, but not the estate out of the girl.

Cheryl is just...eye candy, that is all. Tulisa can at least hold a note and write a song. Cheryl is famous because she's pretty. And pretty she definitely is.

Hahaha

Tulisa

Music: 3
Judging: 6
Image: 3
Current: 2
Looks: 6
Voice: 6
TOTAL: 26

Cheryl

Music: 6
Judging: 3
Image: 6
Current: 4
Looks: 7
Voice: 2
TOTAL: 28

Cheryl Wins. (barely)

Tulisa

Music: 5
Judging:8
Image: 5
Current: 5
Looks: 7
Voice:6

Total-36

Cheryl

Music: 7
Judging:6
Image: 8
Current: 6(will probably be 9/10 once X Factor begins)
Looks: 9
Voice:3

Total- 39

Cheryl wins.

By Current I mean how there spoke about in the industry etc today. How current they..

Fair enough but when rating & comparing two singers vocals shouldn't it be based on vocal ability live over how the vocals sound in the studio?

Yes Cheryl's had a few bad performances. we all have bad days.

but she's great here; Snow Patrol & Cheryl Cole : 'Set The Fire To The …: http://youtu.be/lVjQYbX-F7k