Rob Killed Tina. Yeah we knew that last night. Might aswell have had her die from the fall. Also Tina is bloody stupid, you don't threaten someone who just tried to kill you when you're in a vulnerable state.
But what was the point of her getting up? So there could be no doubt that he actually killed her? I am very underwhelmed. Plus given that Corrie villains always get their comeuppance I was hoping it would be Peter who is leaving anyway or Tracy who I would prefer to leave. I don't mind Rob.
Am I the only one who doesn't beleive Robs character would do that? Spoilt a great twist there. Disappointed again! Would have been better for someone else to have finished her off!!
Originally Posted by OhWhenTheSaints: “A bigger twist would have been to have one of the other 3 push her off last night and then Rob come across her tonight and it playing out as it did.”
yeah Carla, then we would have had a confrontation scene
Originally Posted by Rich_Wilson: “Am I the only one who doesn't beleive Robs character would do that? Spoilt a great twist there. Disappointed again! Would have been better for someone else to have finished her off!!”
Agree.... I know he's got form, but he was so relieved that Tina hadn't died from the fall,no way would he have done that......... all her shouting about attempted murder, would have been her word against his....
We should have been given a confrontation with Carla before the scene where her and Rob were on the balcony. Then while Rob was making it look like a burglary, Tina should have got up and Tony should have seen her, she should have started mouthing off to him only for Tony to smash her head in with the metal pipe.
My ending would have been: Rob dashes off from the scene of the crime as he was, Carla emerges from the pub to confront Tina and tells Michelle to go back inside....Carla finds Tina coming round from her fall, big confrontation, Tina goads Carla who at breaking point smashes the iron bar over her head. Now there's a twist for you
Originally Posted by priscilla: “We should have been given a confrontation with Carla before the scene where her and Rob were on the balcony. Then while Rob was making it look like a burglary, Tina should have got up and Tony should have seen her, she should have started mouthing off to him only for Tony to smash her head in with the metal pipe.”
Why would she have been mouthing off to Tony though? I know loads of people wanted Tony to be the killer but I think that would have been complete rubbish and totally unbelievable, have they ever even shared a scene together
Originally Posted by _NiallDEE_: “Why would she have been mouthing off to Tony though? I know loads of people wanted Tony to be the killer but I think that would have been complete rubbish and totally unbelievable, have they ever even shared a scene together ”
Because he's involved in the crime of the century - the stolen hairdryers. It's worth dying for, apparently.
Originally Posted by _NiallDEE_: “Why would she have been mouthing off to Tony though? I know loads of people wanted Tony to be the killer but I think that would have been complete rubbish and totally unbelievable, have they ever even shared a scene together ”
Yes, she knows about his dodgy deals, even if it wasn't Tony I thought when they said twist it would be someone else who actually kills her but Rob thinks he did.
Originally Posted by Rich_Wilson: “My ending would have been: Rob dashes off from the scene of the crime as he was, Carla emerges from the pub to confront Tina and tells Michelle to go back inside....Carla finds Tina coming round from her fall, big confrontation, Tina goads Carla who at breaking point smashes the iron bar over her head. Now there's a twist for you”
I agree, this is definitely what should have happened. It should have involved two people attacking her to add mystery when one thinks it was just them that attacked her.
Originally Posted by Rich_Wilson: “My ending would have been: Rob dashes off from the scene of the crime as he was, Carla emerges from the pub to confront Tina and tells Michelle to go back inside....Carla finds Tina coming round from her fall, big confrontation, Tina goads Carla who at breaking point smashes the iron bar over her head. Now there's a twist for you”
That would have been a twist, but then would Carla have it in her to kill Tina. Look at Frank, he raped her and was soo horrible to her at the factory on the night he got killed but she still didn't kill him.
Was a bit of a letdown to be honest. Like other posters have said, Rob should have run off, leaving Carla to confront Tina and then Carla bashing her round the head. Rob would have thought he had killed her.
That would have been much more interesting.
I think Carla should have pushed her, Carla phones Rob out of panic and he finds Tina while she's coming too. She mouths off to him about how she's going to ruin Rob, Carla, Tracy and Peter's lives and Rob hits her to protect himself, his sister and his fiancee.
Well it was a massive twist to me because I didn't expect her to get up and keep talking, and I certainly didn't expect Rob to MURDER her. We can forget manslaughter... that was murder and it was messy.
My jaw was on the floor when she started moaning and then talking.