Originally Posted by Dorkus_:
“She had the same reaction Carole, Kathreya, Wolfy-like reaction. Someone that stands out and people get behind for being quirky and slightly different to everyone else.
As we've seen with all of the above this can wear thin after a couple of weeks. It'll be interesting to see if she can maintain this happy-go-lucky persona.”
It also helps to be not very good looking or thin, and we can add at least bb8's Laura to the list and perhaps Becky from bb13 (and others I don't remember right now).
The wild enthusiasm for Shievonne in bb13 should also be mentioned, even though it wasn't a launch night phenomenon but was instead based largely on one "entertaining" performance in the DR.
But although it can help to lack looks at the start, I don't think there's ever been a forum favourite female with lasting popularity who wasn't good looking, except perhaps for Nadia back in the bb5 days.
Originally Posted by Alrightmate:
“Perhaps. But I didn't warm to any of the housemates you've listed on their launch nights anyway. I saw right through that Kathreya cookie bullshit right from the start. However even if it's all contrived bullshit this time as well, I think Pauline actually could be a housemate I might genuinely like.
I could be wrong though.”
Yes, some people always thought Kat was contrived. But BB8 started on 30 May and it wasn't until the 28th of July that the "implied probability" version of the betting odds started showing a generally steady fall in Kat's chances of winning. The highest peak in her implied probability was near the end of June. So her popularity lasted pretty well for two months.