Originally Posted by Dixon:
“I was a big fan of Oscar, but he's lost his way since Jose arrived.
He's now had two consecutive poor seasons that have simply not been good enough for a title winning team!
Willian is an Everton/Euro level player. When he came on for Brazil in the WC he was the worst player in the worst Brazilian team in history! He literally did nothing but run around like a headless chicken and gave the ball away time and again.
His fans say he does the unglamorous hard work, while I say he does the simple easy work and 'passes the buck' whenever it comes to the really difficult things to do on a football pitch, which is to score and create goals.
Would any top European team, past and present, have an attacking midfielder with zero end product in their team? I say that's a big fat no! We won the title inspite of him!
If we had a player in his position who actually scored and created their fare share, then we wouldn't need Ivan bombing forward trying to do something that Willian should be doing. Ivan could stay back and concentrate on defending and that would make Willian completely redundant!
We will not make any further progress with Willian taking up a first team space!
Without Hazard and Costa, we would have been ouside the top 6 last season, such was the dire lack of contribution from Oscar and Willian. We cannot afford to go into another season with everything resting on Hazard and Costa!”
We must have been watching different games in the World Cup, I thought Oscar was one of the few Brazilian players to come out of that debacle with any credit. But Scolari was worse than useless as a manager. If you look around the world at the talent Brazil had (and still have) at their disposal, a decent manager should have been able to build a formidable squad. Not necessarily to win the whole thing, but at least go pretty close.
I mean, picking Fred as their CF ? Rickie Lambert or Charlie Austin could have done a better job, they might as well have started with 10 men.
I completely disagree with you about the skill levels of Willian and Oscar, neither would look out of place in any of the top teams in Europe.
Where I do agree with you (to a certain extent) is in having those two, together with Fabregas, in the same team. As you say, we do need more firepower and can't continue to rely solely on Costa and Hazard to come up with the goods.
We haven't replaced Lampard, perhaps we never will. But we do need someone in midfield who can at least get into double figures in terms of goals. That doesn't mean I want to see the back of Willian, Oscar or Fabregas. I'm happy with each of them when they're on form. But there are other players around who are past their best or who clearly aren't going to make the grade. Move those on first and bring in a more attacking midfield player or winger with an eye for goal, that's what I'd like to see.