IMO it goes

1. Andy - Perfect social game, a few strategic mistakes but nothing major
2. Judd - Had a strong strategic and social game for the majority of the game but he did make a few too many mistakes
3. McCrae - Started off as a strong player but turned in to the shows biggest idiot
4. Amanda - Good strategic game, very manipulative but completely awful social game
5. Helen - Went from very strong in the first half of the game but then completely lost the plot and became the most idiotic strategic player, I'm only putting her high because of her good moves early on
6. Aaryn - Good at competitions but made some huge social and strategic crimes
7. Spencer - Did well to lay low convincingly and I actually think his game play is under rated, just he make some very stupid moves
8. Elissa - Had a good mindset on the game but was too scared to pull off good moves
9. GinaMarie - Didn't even get to the final 2 based on her gameplay, people carried her trough the whole way since they knew they could beat her
10. Jessie - A pretty weak overall player but not terrible
11. Nick - Didn't see enough of him to accurately judge but he looked like he had potential, just he made a few silly moves
12. Howard - Had a good social game at first but it was ruined by his idiotic strategic game
13. Candice - A pretty weak player, never did anything very good game wise
14. Kaitlin - Good at competitions but weak otherwise
15. Jeremy- Amazing at competitions, TERRIBLE socially and stragetically
16. David - Stupid, deserved to be first out

As much as I hate his personality I think Andys the only one who didn't make any completely stupid game moves

1. Andy - good strategic and social game. Basically paved the way to the end easily.
2. Judd - strong social player, which blocked him from getting to the end.
3. Amanda - amazing controlling game.
4. Helen - same as Amanda.
5. Elissa - turned an obvious first boot into an interesting player and was the first person to make a move against Amanda.
6. Candice - yes, believe it or not I think she was great. Very VERY intuitive (worked out the Moving Company easily etc. etc. ) and a very smart player. Sadly couldn't do anything about it because Aaryn and GM just hated her for no reason.
7. GinaMarie - first person to actually nominate Amanda but her jury management is by far the worst ever that she got pulled through the game based on everyone knowing she would get very few votes. Meh.
8. Jessie - knew what was going on in the house, but couldn't do anything about it.
9. McCrae - started off well, made some incredibly dumb moves towards the end.
10. Aaryn - could win competitions, but never did ANYTHING smart with her power. You can say "her game was based on loyalty!!!" well yeah but so was Adam Poch BB13 and he is still one of the worst players ever. She used her power to get Judd out? He was her friend?!
11. Kaitlin - showed promise etc.
12. Spencer - did basically nothing but meh he made final three
13. Howard - let his game easily fall apart and left Candice to pick up the pieces.
14. Nick - had way to big of an ego and played too hard too fast it was painful to watch.
15. Jeremy - one of the worst social players I've ever seen
16. David - ...duh

1. Andy, he played almost a perfect game - practically the same game as Dan the year before but without the advantages and far more subtle. I feel a little bad for Andy because he'll never get the credit he deserves for what was such a good game. Thankfully his personality is horrific and he won 500k... so I don't feel too bad.

2-16. In regards to gameplay the rest were just embarrasing. I really don't even consider the rest that much higher than David in the gameplay stakes. They were all absolutely terrible.

Three out of the entire cast showed promise - McCrae, Judd and Andy. McCrae stopped playing after 3 weeks and couldn't get out of bed. Judd was a ticking timebomb of nerves that made anyone around him suspicious and on edge.

I disagree about Candice and Elissa

I know Elissa was edited to look like the hero of it all but she actually wasn't a very good game player. On the live feeds it was clear that people like Helen and Amanda were doing things for her and they were the ones keeping her in. Had she did what she did and Helen and Amanda never come up with the idea to keep her on then she would have been first out. And she wasn't the first to go against Amanda at all, Howard and Candice were. But if I'd happily give that title to anyone it would be Jessie as out of all of Amanda's targets I'd say she was the first one to play it strategically.

And Candice was smart but it was clear how little we knew about the game. She was way too confrontational and sassy with people which meant nobody trusted her or wanted to work with her. Even when she was a target she just shouted her mouth off and made the game worse for herself.

Took the words right out of my mouth really. I'd say Helen showed promise at the beginning but that's it.

I see where you're coming from but I watched the live feeds and I thought Elissa made good strategic moves at times etc. and I meant she was the first person to actually win a competition and use it to try and take down Amanda (to no avail, sadly). But yeah, overall I'd definitely give it to Candice and Howard. I see a lot of your points but I still maintain she was a strong player who got herself into a good spot and would've lasted a little longer if McCrae didn't make such a stupid move.

My view on Candice might be blurred by the horrible, horrible bullying she suffered in the house but I maintain she was one of the few people who actually knew what was going on in the house, and wasn't blindly led by the two powerhouses of Helen and Amanda. I agree about the sassiness, that definitely impaired her game.