Originally Posted by frost:
“Rooney might under perform at actual world cups, but he is joint fourth top goal scorer of all time at international level for England. 10 more goals and he becomes the all time top scorer ever. Considering his age there's every chance he will do that.”
These days, it's easier to rack up caps, especially non competitive ones. There are players behind Rooney who played a lot less games for England. Any attacking England forward who plays 80+ caps will be there or thereabouts.
Peter Crouch notched 22 goals at a rate better than one in two (which improves on Rooney's rate) and the argument that he scored against lesser teams is a bit thin as surely "better" players like Rooney should do even better against those same lesser teams.
There's a long list of players who never got anywhere near 94 caps who'd have been up there if they had - Hursr, Hunt, Peters, Keegan, Channon, Lofthouse, Shearer, Platt, Finney and the aforementioned Crouch even. Add the fact Rooney's tournament return is poor and you'll never convince many that he deserves to be mentioned in the same breath as some others who did it when it mattered or did it from midfield. Some of the players listed aren't considered world class either.
The assumption that just because he'll eventually get to the top of the England goals chart through longevity backs up the claims he is world class is simplistic and quite absurd. He's been a decent player but nothing more and has not quite delivered on the greatest stage.
He's international class.