Originally Posted by Grandmother:
“She was in charge of that group for a good two thirds of the series. Do you not recall her being officially warned (more than once?) for'bullying' Freddie?”
We never saw her being warned, only Marcus saying that she had. He did not use the word bullying, or say that it was anything to do with Freddie. He merely said that she was quiet because she had been warned. She continued to be quiet throughout the rest of the series. You remember the timing wrong; once Karly had gone, a third of the way through, lisa ceased to be any kind of leader; and she was never strongly in charge before that. Charlie and Rodrigo never really spent much time with her - it was only Sophie, Karly, Sree, and Noirin who did. From the day Karly went out and David came in, Lisa more or less spent the rest of the series sitting quietly with him in the garden, chatting with whoever was passing, including Freddie. It was only on the forum that people created this false turbo-Lisa, dangling some unspecified housemates from her strings.
Quote:
“ I highly doubt the others (particularly that guy with the hair; I forget his name) would have had the stones to be as unpleasant to Freddie's face if it hadn't been for 'Mum's' approval, tacit and otherwise.”
Kris. Kris didn't care particularly for Lisa, and was certainly not under her thumb. Apart from Sophie, he didn't seem particularly interested in any of the women even as friends. Lisa was not present when he taunted Freddie about the washing up, or when he contrived the game of hide and seek.
Quote:
“ And if spitting venom at every opportunity is your idea of 'pottering harmlessly' that's fine, but I'm guessing most old folks homes would be more complicated places to run if that was a generally accepted definition of the term.”
She did no such thing. I challenge you to think of ONE SINGLE REMARK she made against anyone at all from about a third of the way through the series. All I can think of was her rather bemused comment that Bea was being a bitch when she saw her making her Team M tee shirt.
Quote:
“I agree with most of this; no one in there had Freddie's back, and there was, as you say, no other group. As a result Team Lisa (Team Nana? Team Thunderbird Puppet?) cruised to the final virtually unopposed, while Siavash, Marcus and Freddie, who'd all have been more interesting winners than Sophie, IMVHO, self-destructed in their various ways. It wasn't something I enjoyed watching.”
There were a few days when Freddie, Marcus, Siavash, Tom, Kenneth and Bea held the kitchen - indeed boasted about how uncomfortable they would make it for anyone else to use the kitchen - while Freddie ranted on about who had gameplans. But they just got bored. It was obvious that Tom had no interest in the show, Bea fell out massively with Freddie, Marcus was actually quite pally with Charlie and Siavash with Sophie and it was hard to stir up much hate against Lisa and David since all they seemed to do from dawn to dusk was sit in the garden making inconsequential remarks about the weather and what they were having for tea.
In the end, the split ended up more generational: Marcus and Lisa warmed to each other, and the finalists started to take the mick out of David and Lisa and their Terry and June standard repartee.