Originally Posted by od hominem:
“I'm minded to agree with this. There does seem to be the attitude amongst certain politicos that education exists purely to prepare you for the work place, rather than a means of attaining knowledge for its own sake.”
Or indeed education existing as some sort of badge. My neighbour is a university lecturer and she describes a big change in the last decade. She finds that each year many freshers arrive ill equipped to take advantage of the degree courses they pay for.
She talks of the inability to write or to think and students unable to research or listen to information and put two apparently disparate ideas together and reach a conclusion. I think we see a lot of that in BB and oe here which is how I came ( perhaps unfairly ) to connect the two ideas.
University lecturers are now in the unfortunate position of students now feeling that they buy their degrees, which in a sense they do. So the expectation is that they pay their money and turn up for three years and voila they get qualified. Yet she finds they don't have the basic skills to meet the traditional requirements of essay writing etc.
Complaints against universities are on the rise. A significant proportion of those who complain about their grade and feel that the university should have done more in terms of spoon feeding to get them a higher mark. This WAS not what a university was supposed to be about. It was supposed to be about providing resources and guidance so that people learned to learn and think for themselves, not about spoon feeding answers.
When I recruit, I find it very difficult to find people with the necessary skills to write a decent business letter or e mail, for example. I don't have this problem when I recruit older women (older men rarely apply for service work) its the younger people that have this difficulty. They are the lion's share of applicants and few are fit for relatively simple and low skilled work.
To be fair many of them know more about how e mail works ( such as the hidden functionality) and can whizz around the net and social media in a way that leaves me breathlessly plodding behind. But when they get to where they are going they don't seem able to use the information or express themselves in writing. Its like a dog chasing a cat, when they catch them they don't know what to do with them.
Employers expect to teach people how to listen to customers, how to listen and how to analyse the problem, in the context of that specific operation. They don't expect to have to teach their staff to write a response in proper sentences or structured such that it can be understood by the customer or that reflects well on the professional image of the business. I think employers are also entitled to expect a general understanding of the world and a basic general knowledge from someone who has had 12 years of state education.
Meanwhile other countries are stealing a march on us. My worry is that we, our economy will fall behind. We also have an issue with youth unemployment. But within the general youth unemployment there is a core who just don't have satisfactory skills to do the jobs. It feels like that core is getting bigger. Yet as a society we seem to be at best enabling poor skills and at worst applauding them.
I can't help wondering, when I read some of the attitudes expressed on these boards, if part of the problem is that it has somehow become infra dig or prejudiced to notice poor literacy or poor thinking skills. As I said earlier it is frowned upon as if it were a racist or homophobic comment. But I don't feel it should be. People are the race or orientation they are. To me it is no different to being blue or brown eyed, left or right handed. But to chose ignorance and then demand to be judged equally overlooking this detail seems bizarre.