No way he sang as well as Dawn! This is not fair, surely?

I know........Dawn was much better than Reggie tonght.

There is no way that is fair

Dawn had a shit song. She was never going to get many votes.

I thought she really raised her game tonight, whereas Reggie coasted through in the same old way without any visible (or audible) improvement. Deeply unfair.

She did well with it, poor girl!

Gutted. I thought Dawn was lovely.

Well done Reggie, not sure how you did it but good luck to you lad!!!

EDIT: (not sure how you leave those notes at the bottom the page) - I thought Reggie was AWFUL and Dawn fantastic but clearly his votes are making a difference so who cares ... he can't sing but well done to the Reggie fans for picking up the phone, I hope Dawn gets offered something musical and I hope she does brilliantly! For me ... Kim to win ... I LOVE to be entertained but I love good singing above anything!!!!

Do you have aproblem with charity? Its not about who can sing best - its about money for disadvantged people.

Not at all. But for me (totally subjective) at some point I will vote onthe perormance (vocally et al)

I got a little precious, I do apologise, I want Ade to win, but HATE it when somebody who is neither talented NOR entertaining gets through (Reggie - also his pathetic "humour" aginst Manchester United annoyed me hugely) I have to support the others.


I want to see Ade do Robbie Williams ' "Radio" - was driving through town today and thought how great it would be.


xxx
Last edited by Evilredzebra : 08-03-2005 at 23:33

Many people seem to miss the point that good singing is entertaining.

His humor toward ManU gains votes from me I'd like ade to win too but I'm not sure about Radio. The only Robbie song I don't like.

Well said!!

Leave Reggie alone, he's doing great. Of all the celebrities he had the lowest public profile pre-show and I think he has done incredibly well. He freely admits that he can't sing but who cares? This is Comic Relief Not Get Your Knickers In A Twist Because The Best Singer Isn't Winning!'

Kim is good but I suspect is taking it more seriously than she would freely admit! I can't warm to her but I think she will probably win.

VOTE REGGIE - YOU KNOW IT'S IN THE SPIRIT OF COMIC RELIEF.

I like Reggie and I was sorry to see Dawn go but think Reggie should stay as he is the one improving, I also hate Man U so he gets my vote there.
I'd like to see Debra go next I can't stand her, Ade should win.

I didn't think Dawn was that good and to be honest, I never found her all that appealing. Reggie is at least an endearing personality and his singing has really improved. I was dying to get rid of him in the first few shows, but now I'm finding him quite entertaining!

I agree, I didn't like him to begin with. Now I find myself hoping to hear his name called out as safe!

Dawn is a better singer, and if this was for a record contract I would have prefered Dawn to go through, but it isn't. It's for Comic Relief and I am enjoying watching Reggie

Angie xxx

I agree. I think Reggie himself knows he shouldnt be there cos, as he says, he can't sing. But I too find myself hoping he is called out as safe and you can't deny that he is 10 times better now than he was at the beginning!

Reggie said he wanted to leave on at least two occasions yesterday and I'm wondering if that's because he knows he shouldn't be there based on his singing and is getting uncomfortable watching people he considers better than himself, leaving before him.

I don't think Reggie is a great singer, but I don't think he's ever claimed to be

I missed his United joke/taunt as I was actually watching football on both ITV channels (ah the joy of digital). Whatever Reggie said was probably usual banter for football fans, he is an Arsenal fan (and they don't usually get on with United fans). I'm a 'cockney' Liverpool fan and occasionally make the odd joke about opposing teams (but I don't hate any team)

Anyway I don't think there's much chance of him surviving tonight, unless he pulls off a blinder and gets in top 3

I think it's the fact he knows he's never going to be a really good singer that makes me like him. Nick always seemed to have the idea he was actually quite good, which just put me off him, but I think Reggie deals really well with being told he's rubbish night after night.

One of my best mates is a Gooner but we try to make allowances for his obvious weakness! It just gave me one more reason to want Reggie out really!!!

Am now worried for the fabulous Ade - watching his singing lesson with Carrie his voice is sooooooooo croaky that I reckon he could do some permanent damage. If the odious Reggie beats him tonight I shall call the talent police!

reggie has a lot of fans because he is more into the spirit of the show than say dawn, he isnt a singer he is doing this for charity having a laugh now, and is very entertaining.
I started liking dawn, but she started taking it all to seriously and then vocaly whent downhill. Im glad that out of who is left that she is now gone.
next Edith, Then deb.
Ade, reggie and Kim for final 3 with kim to win.

yeah stop bein mean about reggie! he's the best and i wanted him 2 win even tho he hasnt got the greatest voice, he still has the best personality and he's sooo cute! and he was trying his hardest, its not his fault that his voice isnt as good as others.. but to me his voice sounds proper great anyway reggie is the bestest xXx

anyway its all just for comic relief and its just about raising money, not about who sounds the best so i think reggie did very well.. well they all did actually