Originally Posted by Chris1964:
“I think there was. Steve Williams will probably know for certain.”
Hope nobody's been waiting with baited breath for my views on this. Caught In The Act was absolutely the most shameless rip-off, it was also really late to the party as well, beginning in January 1992 when You've Been Framed had already been on for two years. Might have been alright if they'd done it a year earlier but no, it was absolutely shameless.
There was certainly a game aspect to it because one of the big complaints was that it didn't have enough clips in it (although of course You've Been Framed wasn't all clips for many years, because there wasn't enough material in the early days of camcorders). I think it might have been just a straight audience vote but stretched out to ridiculous lengths, I remember the punters standing behind monitors with their videos on them. And of course we had Shane The Legend Richie's banter with his "foreign correspondents". I think Shane was a bit of an acquired taste in those days, he had quite an aggressive act which put a lot of people off.
I think there's an episode of it on YouTube but I've never plucked up the courage to watch it. But it was a huge show, I think even the last episode, despite its appalling reviews, was clearing ten million. People were still watching it even if they hated it because the chance to see clips like this was still enough of a novelty to put up with the crap presentation. And it was also on Fridays at 8.30 which, previously, was a dreadful slot for the Beeb, pre-watershed Fridays were always weak on BBC1 in those days, Russ Abbott had been sent there on his way to the axe the previous autumn, so it wasn't just getting big ratings by default because it had no competition, people were specifically tuning in to see it. I reckon it must have doubled the slot average, at least.
I remember the Telegraph billing the last episode and saying "The ratings have been huge but the question is, will BBC1 dare to bring it back for a second series?", because it was so controversial for being derivative and brash and populist. And of course they didn't. But every time anyone slags off The Voice or Tumble for being crass or ratings chasing, I always think of Caught In The Act. It was a million times worse than anything you'd ever see now. I think it's maybe hard to explain for people who weren't there at the time. If you've never seen it, it really will shock you.