I'm not sure she is over-rated, because, let's face it, she is the best singer there.

She just does nothing for me. I find her a little bland and her singing lacks real emotion. I also don't like the fact that all the others at some point have attempted quite complex dance moves in their solo stuff, but Kim has never done anything more than a side together, side together - which looks like my mum at a wedding - actually I take that back, my mum is a better dancer, Kim dances more like my dad

Ade sang better than anyone else tonight. It's just not pretty singing, that's all. It's a different genre to the normal talent show fare.

Ade was excellent tonight - for me he has been the best performer throughout (and is an OK singer as well)

I really hope he wins.

I think kim may be in for a shock tomorrow she thinks she has it in the bag but reggie votes will prob go to Ade plus you will have comic relief voters and Ade just might swing it

I find it hard to be vitriolic about anyone left (or anyone who has gone). It's all for "cheridee" and it's been fun.

Kim and Edith have been really good, they've sung live night after night, learning songs in a few takes. How many of today's "stars" actually sing live on stage? Even the so-called professionals (McFly) sounded extremely dodgy tonight (and I still reckon Mariah Carey mimed on the very first FA).

Let's be grateful that we are left with a great final three. The contrasting styles of two very good female singers, and a madcap comic. It's not important that someone doesn't win, just vote for who you think is best.

hear hear comic relief night now dull cos of miss Sandra Dee serious overrated actress ...ok I don't watch soaps .... sorry soap fans

The problem with Edith is that she has some seriouys tuning issues sometimes and therefore, I cannot compare her to the likes of Alex Parks, who in comparison did not have such serious tuning problems.

I agree with you 100% and kim is such a bimbo...Girsl Aloud spring to mind..Edith is way cool and funny..Kim has no personality at all and has taken this entire thing soooooo seriously.....Edith too has much more range of song types that she jsut slieds into..Kim is on the same old same old...no variety in songs really...ballads end of

She did.

The students also had to mime backing vocals behind her to much mirth (Kevin slapped Malachi and Katie's wrists I seem to remember). She couldn't sing 'live' unless she had 12 hours sleep or some ridiculous exact time.

Ok you win my prize for the best laugh of today..yeah she is sooo wooden isnt she....

As if Edith's a great dancer.

That was funny.

I think it's more a case of she daren't move due to tuning issues. The couple of times she attempted to move more than a little bend of the leg she's gone out of tune, as proved on the duet last night.

Has RP mentioned if he knew Janis Joplin ? I'd be quite suprised if he hadn't

Personally I'm not a fan of Kim, I do think that she sings well, but for me, that's all she does, it doesn't seem that she has any presence or emotion when singing.

I actually quite like Edith's voice, however, she does seem to be a little bit dull, Iv'e never met her and im sure that she is lovely But whenever I have seen her on TV previously I've just found her rather bland

one question can you sing even half as good as she can.
At least she is prepared to give her time up to do this like ALL the others have

I can't - in fact I can't sing a note, but that is kind of irrelevant.

I think most people here admire & respect all the contestants for giving it a go - I can't even begin to imagine what courage that must take. However, this is a forum, and I'm not sure why you think the forum exists if we are only allowed to say positive things about the contestants. I like to discuss the positives and negatives of each performance and my genuine opinion is that however good a voice Kim has, she doesn't appear (on performances to date) to be able to dance. The others, whilst not great dancers, have at least been given routines that show more complex moves.

I think it's good that we all discuss the merits (or not) of each performance, it doesn't mean we feel any less respect for the person, or support the charity any less

I dont think its fair for people to say shes boring because ahe only does ballads. I personally love hearing ballads and she does them really well, thats why she chooses to them.

Ade on the other hand, his strongest point is his performance and he allways puts on a good show for us all to watch. They are all good at different things and we should'nt critsize those who arn't so good at a particular thing, nobody is good at everything, if everyone was the same then it would be boring, thats why this has been so good to watch because there is something in it for everyone, so people should just stop critisizing and enjoy the entertainment.

Because think about it, everybody is so into this show, people have been talking about it all week and this is because of the great entertainment they have brought to the show.

So good on them is all i can say!

Sorry again about the typo's

I totally agree.

We all have our favourites but it is nice to have a variety of people. No one would want all the students like Ade in the Academy just as it would be boring if all the students were as quiet and studious as Kim.

She may have wounded it but Kate killed it off....

Both the finalists are good in their own ways. Vote if you have a strong opinion. Otherwise just pledge money to CR.