I have studied the episode she died, the aftermath episode and the build up to her funeral. I know for certain who it will end up being. I am so certain about this that I would prefer to get the green light from you lot before I post my theory.

Just post it. No matter how much you study it doesn't make it an actual spoiler. So please stop attention seeking.

I'm not even going to try and guess as I've said a million times we have been told we don't even know all the facts yet, there's no point, I don't even understand why people are trying to guess I'm just waiting for it to play out. P

they will not go down the route of having it being Ben or Nick Cotten like people suggested as it is someone who was featured in the episodes as Stacey was on Christmas day 2009. I will post it up tomorrow as I am tired now and will have a lot to type in terms of evidence etc.

I'll look forward to hearing who you think it is and why. I genuinely have no idea who it will be.

Cool, well I have given it a lot of taught and will post all my reasons for it tomorrow. I will just say that I will be shocked if I am wrong.

When looking back at who killed Archie, the answer was always there staring at us but there was so much else going on that we where thrown of. This is no different and it adds up to all the clues DTC has given such as it being tragic, it being an accident and that it makes sense.

I thought we'd already established that Max's hyperactive penis killed Lucy?

Nevertheless, looking forward to reading your theory, Padger!

What an anti-climax

I dont get why you are faffing about OP, if you want to speculate then go ahead but I dont see the need of telling us in advance as that achieves nothing. unless you wanted us to improve your ego by saying we simply cannot wait for your post and the reality is that wont hsppen.

Come on Padge I've been up all night refreshing this thread who is it?!

It was for Max!

Ready and waiting xD

Why do certain people feel the need to seek attention? I mean seriously why tell us you apparently know who the killer/s is/are, even though apparently only four people know, in the world, if there telling the truth, that is! And, there are like 7(?) months left. Lol.
Some people.

lovinglife

usless you are a producer/writer for Eastenders then I very much doubt you know who killed Lucy

you probably have your own theory but that is all

..... Riiiiiiight.

Still waiting.........................................

Aren't you the one that made the thread asking whether you should leave the forum, because its too boring for you? Also you sign of every post with your username....

Ok guys so here it is. After watching the episode she dies and the aftermath episode, followed by the funeral episode etc. I am certain the killer will be Jane and Masood.

Lucy's final episode showed Masood staring at her and wondering if he should approach her and say something.

The aftermath episode showed that Jane knew something had happened before Ian broke the news.

Jane and Masood shared a moment at the funeral in the car which I felt meant a lot more than we are led to believe.

I also want to point out that Jane had no confrontation with Lucy after she found out about the drugs and I believe she went to speak to her that night and something bad happened. Jane and Lucy also have a history with an abortion etc that happened the same year as the 25th anniversary. Of course we will get a lot of twists and turns between now and then with Jay etc but I am confident this will be the final Result.

^^^^
I was waiting all night long for that theory and it doesn't sound too bad.

I said at the start, by which I mean when the storyline was first announced, that Ian would be the killer and nothing has dissuaded me from that line of thought.

I don't think it'll be Jane and if it is, I'll be very disappointed. I don't really mind if it's Masood but I still don't think he would kill someone.

I too suspect them, but Cindy is at the top of my list for the moment. I also think that Ian had another confrontation with Lucy that night that we don't yet know about, as I don't think that what we saw was enough to make him go kerb crawling, even though he has gone with a prostitute (Janine) before.

It will not be Ian guys it would take away from everything . If its Cindy it will be flat out ridiculous. she is Just a new character.

I don't think Jane is involved but Masood is a possibility. He has a dark side and has been very quiet of late. But who would have helped him move the body?? It would take two surely.

Ian is another possibility purely because he is a weasel who is always very happy to let others pay the price for his mistakes.

Jay is another red herring imo, although why was he following Lucy? To warn her off Max, maybe.

I've always thought that it could be Masood and that Shabnam helped him. I don't think it was deliberate, he just wanted to impress Jane by helping Lucy and something went wrong.
Shabnam took the card out of the bin and did not hand it over to the police...has she kept it as insurance in case they get close.