As I followed both teams, I wrote a brief summary of my thoughts on both teams, for Niall, the candidates and the viewers to get an insight.
Team Inspired:
Okay so Team Inspired were a mixed bag. Firstly, although George was the PM, I think at times it would be really easy for me to have thought Roxie was the PM. At times I definitely feel like she railroaded decisions and can be very persuasive, a good and bad thing. Iain was competent throughout, as were the others.
As for the concept and the idea… A theme park in New Delhi, India. Starting with location, I don’t buy this ‘India is a tourist hotspot’ that Roxie in particular seems to believe. Maybe down to personal preference, or maybe just down to the fact that my only personal experience with somebody going to India (to New Delhi in fact) was them getting seriously ill on the water over there and being hospitalised. If we ignore that, it’s still just a really random place and where it gets worse is that I just don’t see the appeal of a science theme park. Like, okay, cool? Well, not really. Theme parks are meant to fun and stuff and an enjoyable time for visitors but … it just leaves a lot to be desired really.
On to the park itself, the rides are also something I’m not overly fond of… There’s one ‘big’ ride, the one in the centre, right? But a park can’t survive with just one major ride because the queues would be intolerable, especially in somewhere like New Delhi where a large proportion of the reasoning was a high population density. There’ll be lots of visitors, but not many ‘big’ rides which just causes mayhem and gives the ‘big’ ride the longest queue ever…
Overall, not great and George’s reasoning behind forcing himself to do the ‘graphical work’ (the layout) isn’t great either as it’s pretty basic and it doesn’t even matter that it isn’t an artistic masterpiece. Just the flow of the layout is really bad, toilets in one corner of the park?
Team Aptitude:
So a VERY different approach to the task. I really love the theme and I think the way you went about designing the rides and the park is a lot better. The idea is a lot less creative in my opinion with just choosing the UK but I actually think it’s a lot more of a realistic concept and something that is actually interesting to me. Something I can visualise on like Rollercoaster Tycoon (a game that I spent many nights of my childhood on!!).
Naruto was a great PM and him and Shadi, although not as active and talkative as Team Inspired, actually bounce off eachother quite well. You both have a lot of passion and drive and Naruto in particular showed a lot of resilience throughout the task when it came to decision making and discussions.
Overall, it’s not perfect, but I think it was a job well done. There’s definitely room for improvement though as I don’t think your pitch is as strong as the other teams in particular and although your product is better, I think it lacks an originality that the other team has shown.