Both producers are constantly slated on here so which producer do you believe is worse. I think Stuart Blackburn is worse as 2013 was one of my favourite years for hollyoaks plus BK previously done a great stint on the show it's just recently he's become worse and worse and he's starting to ruin one of my favourite shows. He did mess up EastEnders. However SB has ruined two soaps completely lost many viewers for each show. Plots are boring, writing is atrocious the cast is awful and I rarely ever see a good things about the show.

Blackburn. Corrie has become very dull, especially recently with things like the library plot.

Kirkwood might be hated on here but Hollyoaks is thriving compared to how it was before his return when it was very nearly axed.

I never knew that but that is close to when hollyoaks livened up again with Lynseys shock death Esther's bullying and the bus crash.

I think they are equally bad in their own ways. Kirkwood and his writers only care about shock value and has little regard for the characters on Hollyoaks. They are in love with dragging out plots forever more than anything else.

Blackburn's writers have made Corrie very boring recently. It's not ridiculous like Hollyoaks is, but it has become in my opinion excruciatingly boring. There is no real drama in the Tina plot as Rob's motivation seemed pretty weak and I think Peter is too pathetic for most to care about him being falsely accused. Then, you have boring things like Lloyd and Andrea and the library plot filling up time meaninglessly.