• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • Entertainment
  • Music
Songs that ended up as novelty songs when they weren't meant to
<<
<
2 of 3
>>
>
mgvsmith
23-08-2014
Originally Posted by thewaywardbus:
“Maybe the fact that no one can give a decent example means that it very rarely happens.”

I don't think there are many but what about 'Living Next door to Alice' that turned into a sort of novelty song. http://youtu.be/iYAt22mWiWc
Grabid Rannies
23-08-2014
Surely Barbie Girl would qualify? If you listen to the lyrics, and take it in the context of Aqua's output in general, it is intended as a 'proper' song (for them, at least). But from the off everyone pretty much had it marked down as the daft Barbie novelty song (testified to in part by being such a massive hit).

Feel free to disagree, but I at least understand what the OP is getting at and I think others are being somewhat pedantic. They didn't mean that the songs have somehow literally metamorphosed from one type of song into another, just that over the years they have now come to be regarded as something of a 'novelty'/joke/not taken seriously etc in popular culture (ie hence the functions/disco point is an apt one).
Leicester_Hunk
23-08-2014
Originally Posted by mushymanrob:
“not sure popularity = novelty..

think the tracks the op cites have been 'karaokefied' , and used as party pieces.”

I think that is what I meant all along
Jon Ross
23-08-2014
If a novelty song is a song that has become a bit of a joke and no one takes seriously, I'd like to nominate Sussudio and The Lady in Red as songs that have become essentially novelty songs that nobody I know would readily admit to actually liking but they sold nevertheless.
Jon Ross
23-08-2014
Originally Posted by thewaywardbus:
“I think people need to learn the difference between novelty songs and popular song along songs.....”

I'd like to suggest they can be both. I give you Chas and Dave.
mushymanrob
24-08-2014
Originally Posted by thewaywardbus:
“Maybe the fact that no one can give a decent example means that it very rarely happens.”

because i think the op meant the 'karaokefication' of tracks as opposed to them becoming novelty...

Originally Posted by Leicester_Hunk:
“I think that is what I meant all along”

... i thought right then!
dodrade
24-08-2014
Let's get ready to rumble is now treated as a novelty record by Ant and Dec but at the time was seen as a standard pop song.
djfunnyman
25-08-2014
Originally Posted by Jon Ross:
“If a novelty song is a song that has become a bit of a joke and no one takes seriously, I'd like to nominate Sussudio and The Lady in Red as songs that have become essentially novelty songs that nobody I know would readily admit to actually liking but they sold nevertheless.”

I was watching the Malcolm in the middle scene the other day where Bryan Cranston dances to Sussudio
ohglobbits
25-08-2014
How about Jona Lewie's Stop the Cavalry. Intended originally as a protest song, because of one line that mentions Christmas, it now lives in the Slade/Shakin Stevens Christmas novelty song box only to be played at festive cheeseathons.
djfunnyman
25-08-2014
I'd class Crocodile Rock as a novelty song
ProgRocker
25-08-2014
Lieutenant Pigeon - Mouldy Old Dough?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aO5GWJJP3FM
Bit of a guilty pleasure of mine

The 70s were full of novelty songs.
dodrade
26-08-2014
Originally Posted by Grabid Rannies:
“Surely Barbie Girl would qualify? If you listen to the lyrics, and take it in the context of Aqua's output in general, it is intended as a 'proper' song (for them, at least). But from the off everyone pretty much had it marked down as the daft Barbie novelty song (testified to in part by being such a massive hit).

Feel free to disagree, but I at least understand what the OP is getting at and I think others are being somewhat pedantic. They didn't mean that the songs have somehow literally metamorphosed from one type of song into another, just that over the years they have now come to be regarded as something of a 'novelty'/joke/not taken seriously etc in popular culture (ie hence the functions/disco point is an apt one).”

Irony often doesn't come across well in music as people just listen to the tune rather than the lyrics, Born in the USA is a good example.
mushymanrob
26-08-2014
Originally Posted by ohglobbits:
“How about Jona Lewie's Stop the Cavalry. Intended originally as a protest song, because of one line that mentions Christmas, it now lives in the Slade/Shakin Stevens Christmas novelty song box only to be played at festive cheeseathons.”

good example!
Kiko H Fan
26-08-2014
Originally Posted by ohglobbits:
“How about Jona Lewie's Stop the Cavalry. Intended originally as a protest song, because of one line that mentions Christmas, it now lives in the Slade/Shakin Stevens Christmas novelty song box only to be played at festive cheeseathons.”

I'd agree with this.
Jona himself has said that the 'christmas' line is just part of the song, yet because of it, the song's been placed squarely on the "Christmas Tunes" bandwagon.

Still, I guess it gets him royalties every year.
dodrade
27-08-2014
Originally Posted by Kiko H Fan:
“I'd agree with this.
Jona himself has said that the 'christmas' line is just part of the song, yet because of it, the song's been placed squarely on the "Christmas Tunes" bandwagon.

Still, I guess it gets him royalties every year.”

It was released in December, mentions christmas and has a brass band and bells on it, what did he expect?
Conehead
27-08-2014
Lazy Sunday Afternoon - Small Faces.
degsyhufc
27-08-2014
Originally Posted by Leicester_Hunk:
“I was thinking about this the other day and I thought of the following that I absolutely hate:

Sweet Caroline
Build Me Up Buttercup
Come On Eileen

The first two at least I don't think were intended as novelty songs, but they have ended up that way because of them being sung by people at parties and weddings who have drunk too much and start waving their arms about and drunkenly lurching to them - I hate them!

Any more songs anyone can think of that have suffered the novelty fate?”

I agree with Sweet Caroline.
At most do's and night outs if it on most don't know the words, probably only just about know Sweet Caroline then the place shakes as everybody shouts BOM BOM BOM!!!
That's all the song is reduced to.

I'd also same similar with Living Next Door to Alice after the Roy Cubby Brown cover of it.
My all
27-08-2014
I kissed a girl by Katy Perry. If that was released in the 90s it would have been a 1 hit wonder. The power of social media and digital marketing eh?
EStaffs90
27-08-2014
I so hope the Teletubbies single - which happened in 1997 - wasn't meant as anything other than a novelty song.
rufus oculus
27-08-2014
I think that of all the songs mentioned here the only true novelty is Mouldy Old Dough. A true novelty record is not something "crap" but something "new". So Telstar would count as it used sounds that hadn't been heard before. O Superman would count as it was an avant garde work that somehow became a pop hit.
Leicester_Hunk
28-11-2014
Originally Posted by rufus oculus:
“O Superman would count as it was an avant garde work that somehow became a pop hit.”

I remember the first time I ever heard that. I got up for school and put my radio on in the bedroom and it was making this weird noise over someone singing, I went to the bathroom and got ready, came back and it was still doing it. I told my dad my radio was bust and he needed to have a look at it.
SuperAPJ
29-11-2014
Originally Posted by rufus oculus:
“O Superman would count as it was an avant garde work that somehow became a pop hit.”

The horror! I know, I just can't appreciate the art behind it.
zerothehero
29-11-2014
Cotton eye joe?
Blondie X
29-11-2014
Mysterious Girl
my name is joe
29-11-2014
almost any single by Queen
<<
<
2 of 3
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map