Originally Posted by dbarnz:
“I think with a show like X Factor, where you only get 2 minutes a week to vocally show what you can do, it can be tempting to shove every note you can hit into a song. For Andrea, as the contestant with the biggest range, it was probably expected of him to do this. I personally didn't find that he over sung any of his performances, but mainly because I interpreted it as pure passion and it never felt forced. I can see where people are coming from though when they say he over sings. Obviously on his album everything will be much more refined.”
“I think with a show like X Factor, where you only get 2 minutes a week to vocally show what you can do, it can be tempting to shove every note you can hit into a song. For Andrea, as the contestant with the biggest range, it was probably expected of him to do this. I personally didn't find that he over sung any of his performances, but mainly because I interpreted it as pure passion and it never felt forced. I can see where people are coming from though when they say he over sings. Obviously on his album everything will be much more refined.”
Andrea has refined taste and never over-ornaments to the point where it grates. However much we love him, there are bound to be some songs that we prefer to others. To be honest, when SCowell made the remark about oversinging I think he was just being nasty.
The only time I have ever heard Andrea add extra notes was when he sang Oh Holy Night and then SCowell trotted out his tired old statement about not liking it but loving it. He was totally inconsistent and insincere. I prefer to rely on Andrea's knowledge of music than SCowell's. The man's a muppet. I know it's so because diabolo said so and he's the Ninja who sees all from the shadows. Are you all counting down? Don't worry , there's a little time to go. Stay vigilant!




Keep your eyes on that post number because I want that 4000th post