Originally Posted by tortfeasor:
“
You're right. In fact, 'Nothing Compares 2 U,' which was mentioned very early on in this thread, could be a good example of the point you're making. As far as I'm aware, it was released by 'The Family' as an album track first (admittedly Prince was just a little bit involved in output credited to 'The Family' ) but a version attributed to him wasn't released until AFTER Sinead had the hit; the live version on 'The Hits/B-sides' has a pretty identical arrangement to what the man himself laid down for The Family.
.”
“
You're right. In fact, 'Nothing Compares 2 U,' which was mentioned very early on in this thread, could be a good example of the point you're making. As far as I'm aware, it was released by 'The Family' as an album track first (admittedly Prince was just a little bit involved in output credited to 'The Family' ) but a version attributed to him wasn't released until AFTER Sinead had the hit; the live version on 'The Hits/B-sides' has a pretty identical arrangement to what the man himself laid down for The Family.
.”
the family album was basically an album prince wrote and recorded himself, bar a few bits such as horns and strings, and then he got paul peterson from the jam and lewis-less time (the version of the time in the purple rain movie) to replace prince's vocals. it's been reported that prince's original vocals were wiped from the master types for pauls vocals, it's not circulating amongst fans whilst the prince vocal versions of the other tracks are.
the originally released version has a lack of drums, whilst the sinead version has the soul 2 soul style drums through it, but is reasonably similar. what few people would know is there was an alternate unreleased mix of the family version which has drums, which were presumably just removed in the final mix, just like the bass was removed from the final mix of when doves cry. so the sinead version is a lot closer to the original idea than most people would know. however sinead shared a manager with paul peterson around the time (she was little known outside of nme readers before that song came out), so they probably heard the original version with drums
prince added it to his live shows after it became a hit, but personally i think it was quite different to the family and sinead versions. there were a couple of main arrangements, the first being prince solo, the second being the one on the hits release which was the duet. the version from his 2014 tour however was very close to the original
prince also played most or all instruments on the original manic monday by apollonia 6 which made it as far as the test pressing but removed from the final release. the bangles version features the main instrumentation by prince with some additional instruments added. i understand susannah hoffs is the only bangle that actually played on the released version. the backing vocals are the other 2 members of A6
i wouldn't say manic monday by the bangles was a cover as it was the first released version, plus it's really the original version with some changes




Whaaaa?!