Originally Posted by Robert_Whippy:
“Her ill be there one is a personal favourite from the recorded performances.”
I am curious to hear what your opinion is about this. Okay she had tonsilitis during that live show, but do the 4 "I'll be there" parts sound good on the recorded version of I'll be there?
I thought her x factor performance was good until the part when she had to sing those higher 4 "I'll be there" notes. If she nailed that song, which I know she can, it would have been in my top 3 Lauren's performances.
However Simon still thought the last 20 seconds were fantastic, so I guess everything really does sound better in the studio during the live shows. It also explains why the comments from the judges about some performances from almost every contestant (including Lauren, they were too easy on her sometimes) were overrated and sometimes quite stupid.
Originally Posted by Robert_Whippy:
“Dark horse however both live and recorded is my least favourite. shes ok in this song but i just feel it doesnt sound like her usual voice. maybe im just imagining it.”
I personally prefer Dark horse over Let it go, Clarity and maybe I'll be there. Vocally I think it is okay and I think the higher note at the end is good, but she seems to be very uncomfortable with the choreography, I don't have the same feeling about her How will I know performance (although she made a small mistake near the end there with the word "whenever", I still love that performance).
Originally Posted by Robert_Whippy:
“I dont mean this in an insulting way, in fact its the opposite but she sounds better in the recorded performances than her lives. not that i dont think shes good live just that shes better as a recording artist.
i think she'll be a great recording artist and a good live performer. i think with experience the latter will become even better. shes good at both but better at being a recording artist.
however If i had to make one criticism and what i think is more appropriate as a constructive criticism is that her voice on some particular songs still needs to mature a bit more. thats my one criticism. sometimes you can tell you are listening to a 17 year old girl.”
Glad to hear that she sounds good as a recording artist, I just hope they won't autotune her voice too much when she starts releasing her own music. Overall I think she is a good live singer. Her voice will mature I guess, although I love her voice even the way it is now. She has a lot of potential in my opinion to get better and I am sure she will, both vocally and in stage presence.
Originally Posted by Robert_Whippy:
“However not all of her performances gave that impression for example Smile. she sounded like a woman in that one. Just think her voice is still growing and still maturing”
Yup, I agree. There are many better singers than her out there, but there is something about her voice that I absolutely love, especially during her Smile performance.
Originally Posted by Snowyday2:
“
And Lauren might not be at Tour Rehearsals on Wednesday
”
No worries if she misses that one rehearsal as long as she stays healthy, attends the rest of them and gives people good performances on tour...no mistakes hopefully, she can't afford to make them this time.