Originally Posted by wizzywick:
“Well, I did catch up with episode 1. Everyone is raving about it as if it's the best drama ever created! "It will win tons of awards!" says he! "Oh it's got BAFTA all over it" says another! Well, here's my opinion. It was a good drama. It was well acted. It was very respectful in its handling of the whole thing. But, it wasn't groundbreakingly brilliant. It wasn't so fabulous that I found I had to tune in the next night - a sentiment shared by many when you look at the ratings for last night. I personally don't identify with it as a clear BAFTA success. Cilla was miles better. Remember Me was miles better. As short drama serials go, it was OK. But, I really have a problem with dramatising things like this. I remember a few years ago when BBC1 made a drama about the prostitutes being murdered (sorry I can't recall the name of the drama - nor the location as to where it took place), and I felt as uncomfortable watching that as I did watching this.
I also suspect that those decrying "BBC fans" or "The Usual Suspects" wouldn't have even bothered watching it had it been on BBC1 because it is highly likely "Cheryl's Glittering Handbag of X-Factor Dropouts" type of show that is normally on ITV in its place would have been the chosen viewing vehicle for "the ITV usual suspects".”
Those decreeing it should win BAFTA's, awards etc. on the drama thread do for most dramas that are cut above the rest, either on BBC1 and ITV. Just like for Happy Valley, Marvellous, Cilla, even The Missing.
I haven't seen anyobody suggest its the best drama ever created, if they have point it out to me. But what your suggesting is exactly the same as when a BBC drama has an impact. This thread if filled with posters fawning over a drama, praising it to high hills.
Let's face it some on here stick to their favourite channel and do not budge from 'Channel 1', and will not watch ITV. Others are more open to watching a broad range of channels, like me I watch BBC One dramas, BBC Two dramas, ITV, occasionally Ch4 (but not very often).
If it was on BBC1 I would have watched it, like I have done with The Missing, Remember Me etc.