Originally Posted by trevor tiger:
“I don't think people are impatient and or incapable of enjoying a long or drawn out story line. I'm actually quite offended by the constant accusation of this tbh. I feel the point has been made very clear that some people are questioning the reality aspect. I appreciate Mick is now very much switched on to there being something wrong with Linda but he undoubtedly has a very bad habit of jumping in and speaking for Linda and jumping to unhelpful conclusions. Then lo and behold, after doing what might seem the right thing and bringing in Linda's mum, she does EXACTLY the same thing.
My problem is that EE are perhaps unrealistically elongating this story line for the increased effect of the eventual reveal and it leaves a bad taste quite frankly.”
Well, unfortunately
some people are impatient and/or incapable of enjoying a long/drawn s/l, I afraid. Those kinds of people do exist on these forums.
I appreciate the questioning of the s/l's reality. But I see the writing of it a litlle differently. It depends on whose POV or lens you are seeing the events.
Mick et al jumping in and speaking for Linda, for instance, is something I admit irritiated me but I also had to see his interruptions in light of what was happening to Shirley (his mother and member of the family) from his POV. The shooting was the main event to affect the family and, like all the people who Linda sought to reach out to, every member of the family (mis)read Linda's behaviour through the lens of the events of that day: the wedding (drunken Maid of Honour) and the shooting (Shirley Carter, a family relative). Even Sharon thought Linda her friend came over to see how if she (Sharon) and Phil was OK, and it was through that lens/perspective that Sharon spoke with Linda. So I can understand the jumping in bit, however annoying it was. And it does make sense.
As for Elaine, remember that she would have known about Mick's 'daliance' (sp?) with a hooker. That was the last time she and Linda left things. So Elaine comes to the family thinking it was still an on-going drama about her daughter's marital relationship with Mick. Hence, her thinking that the problem was to do with Linda having an affair/fling of her own as some kind of revenge. So again from
her POV it makes sense that Elaine would assume that position, especially if Linda isn't that forthcoming on things.
It also makes sense from Linda's POV. Every conversation she has with someone, every little gesture is magnified in light of what happened to her. She now reads meanings in everything she sees and hears where there are none. So again I can understand how the whole s/l becomes elongated. It also adds to the idea of why rape victims find it difficult to talk about what happened to them. It's not just the violation of the physocal act but the psychological one which is not something that can be got across/represented on the TV screen easily.
Originally Posted by duckylucky:
“There are posters also who feel its difficult to watch . I have expressed that I find it painful to watch Linda in such distress
I would like it resolved soon , not because I have no patience but simply because I am not sure I can watch her distress till Christmas . It stresses me to watch her
I think its quite judgemental to presume people have a short attention span because they are finding this hard to watch for a long period”
Actually, I am not judging people's attention span. Nothing in my post suggested or hinted at that. If anything I mentioned people's impatience. I admit I should have said said 'some' people are impatient tbf (because they exist) and not give such a broad generalisation of everyone. Like you, I hate watching Linda's distress and I hate more the jumping to conclusions by some characters. But that's only because I sometimes fail to see the s/l from the POV of all the characters invloved and not just Linda. This s/l will after all affect every member of the Carter family once the truth is revealed. And i think that it is the whole point this s/l is making: it is not rape by a stranger, but familial rape (rape within the family by a family member).