Originally Posted by davrosdodebird:
“...wow. Such hatred for a character we see so little of.
"this Danny Pink crap"
Wow. Just wow.
Who went and made YOU a Hugo winning script writer? Cos that's one heck of a well balanced, thought out and eloquently stated opinion that I have no chance in hell of even beginning to respond to it.
People seem determined to hate him. Why?? Is it because he isn't a pair of boobs on legs? Is it because he makes Clara less "available"? Is it because he has no wish to travel on the TARDIS? Or is it because he's not Rose fricking flying Tyler?
Seriously though the continued and unconditional hatred for Pink is staggering. I wasn't too sure about him myself at first, but tonight's episode changed that for me. He came across as genuinely caring for the kids and clara, though he took no nonsense and demanded of people only what he would give them. The idea that Pink has seen enough danger that he has learned to appreciate the normal, mundane stuff that even the Doctor has said before he loves about humans, is something I find refreshing and new.
And did anyone notice the Doctor actually used his name in the end? I am liking the character arcs this series.
And please stop spouting this "crappy soap opera" rubbish as if it's new. Fans with an axe to grind have been using that one since the 1980s.”
Wow. Such anger and hostility at something as trivial as somebody stating an opinion. On a discussion board, of all places. Wow. Just wow.
Some people don't like the character (I don't really mind him). There's absolutely nothing wrong with them saying that. Is this not a discussion forum for Doctor Who? Why not simply add to the discussion and explain your view on the matter?
You say that the dislike for Danny is "staggering". I, for one, would say that your angry, overly-dramatic reaction to this thread is more staggering.
And no, people shouldn't have to "stop spouting this "crappy soap opera" rubbish" if that's how they feel. Paraphrasing your good self, who went and made YOU the lord and master of the forum who gets to dictate what people can and can't say? Please, I'd love to know where you get the authority.
As for the "Hugo award winning script writer" comment, there aren't enough facepalms in the universe. It's rather ironic that you slam the "soap opera" critique as being overused, because that style of comeback - ("You didn't like this show / movie, etc? ARE YOU A WRITER?! HUH?! HUH?") is tediously overused itself. The very suggestion that one must be a script writer in order to be allowed to form opinions on a television show is beyond absurd, and a transparently weak attempt to shout down an opinion someone doesn't agree when they seem incapable of just explaining their counter-opinion.
Seriously, the amount of posts I see where people respond to opinions with which they disagree with bizarrely angry tirades, instead of taking the chance to actually use the forum for it's actual purpose and explain their view on the subject, is tiresome now. It's like some people sign up to discussion forums and then expect everyone to think exactly the way they do.
You know, if this opinion on Danny is "continued and unconditional" (I haven't been frequently on here this series so I wouldn't know), perhaps it would be wise to just stop entering those threads, rather than entering them just to tell people to stop having the audacity to post their opinion simply because you've now started to like him.