First of all, I'm not saying she was great. But she has shown a lot of improvement and there is no way she deserved to be lower than Scott Not sure what Craig was thinking. In fact, I have heard people argue that Allison wasn't any better than Judy either. These past two weeks Judy has actually done a couple of decent dances and I wish the marks last night reflected that more.

I wonder if the judges had a mark in mind, based on the rehearsals, which Anton suggested went terribly!

Almost everyone seemed to think Judy was better than Scott, and many thought she was better than Allison too. At the very least, she's making very visible progress, while Allison seems to have stalled.

It seems cruel for the actual score to revert close to the one given on week 1, but I think that's partially an artifact of the judges wanting to maintain a spread in the scores as everyone gets better, rather than genuinely thinking she's no better.

I agree with you. I thought she deserved a better position on the leader board - certainly above Scott (and maybe Alison). She's not delusional about her ability but you can see the hard work she put in to improving her performance skills so it would have been nice to be rewarded for that by the judges. Scott, on the other hand, is a bit delusional and thinks he's making progress, but it must be in ways invisible to the naked eye . I did wonder if they were being kind to Scott on purpose, so people didn't vote out of sympathy.

No way...but Scott and Alison were overmarked in my estimation.

I agree she should definitely have had a better score than Scott and personally I would have put her equal to Alison.

She should have been above Scott & Alison.

Judy is improving a little bit each week but Alison & Scott aren't.

overmarked, undermarked, wombling free

She was better than Scott by some long way. He was wildly over marked so they'd have had to mark her higher than that to have been fair (to her). And that would have troubled Alison's placement. Judy, isn't a good dancer but you can see she is trying and improving... Albeit from a very poor start. I think she was better than Scott and Alison both, neither of whom know what their feet are for.